Quote Originally Posted by inCore View Post
I think the issue is that this does not make me roll my eyes, I actually think it looks rather good. Sure there is room for improvement, the Mechs are a little stationary and the voice acting isn't perfect, blablabla, but it somehow seems like these are things that can be fixed quite easily.

I'm also not a hardcore Mechwarrior fan, I played MW 3 and Mech Commander 2, that's it, and I still think this looks pretty good.
I would say I'm quite a hardcore Mw/Btech fan, I've played just about every Mw game there is (except one of the Mw2 and Mw3 expansions), read numerous books (and still reading) etc... not played the table top game though, I hear its not too different to Warhammer 40,000 table top games which I have played before

While I can definitely see issues with what we've been shown, I'm remaining highly optimistic for the final product, I put this down to being hugely starved of Mechwarrior games. This can be a bad thing however as regardless of how good/bad it is it'll most likely still sell very well.