I am not sure if this information alone can help us get to any conclusions, that's why I insisted on owners of fast SSD storage.
The idea behind this, is to post some numbers involving small reads/writes (where the difference is more obvious) along with your motherboard and storage specs and in combination with information from Everest (or any other program that provide such information).
This way we could cross reference the results with existing ones on the net and see whether your X58-based ICH10 offers similar or seriously degraded performance.