Quote Originally Posted by trinibwoy View Post
No you said that Doom 3 was just bump mapping everywhere which isn't a subjective opinion - it's a claim about the game engine which is patently false. I don't have an opinion on the game itself since I never played it.
so because i know what bump mapping is, its technical criticism?
i have no idea about programming a game... for all i know jc is a genius or at least pretty damn smart at what he does, that doesnt mean everybody will like their games though...

im pretty sure his goal wasnt to make doom3 the most technological advanced and awesome looking game, not at all... he wanted to play with light and shadows and wanted (or was pushed to) make the game run acceptably on even weak old gpus.