Page 6 of 7 FirstFirst ... 34567 LastLast
Results 126 to 150 of 159

Thread: using car radiators...why not?

  1. #126
    Xtreme Addict
    Join Date
    Jul 2006
    Location
    Usa
    Posts
    1,166
    Hi Alex,

    The bulk of my setup will be 1" pvc pipe, but I plan on using this stuff--initially:

    General Purpose Air and Water Hose

    I already have 1/4", 1/2" and 1" collecting dust, so I am going to incorporate the 1" into the system. It can handle the pressure, its aquarium safe (so it shouldn't affect the PC components) and is great for low temps. My only question is: What about high temps!.....??? We'll see. I'll probably contact USPlastics and find out the specs on it.

    Anyway, I may or may not be able to use that tubing to connect to the inlet (1-5/16") on the rad. If not, no big deal--I'll just find some 1-1/4" tubing and do the "heat treatment" if necessary. My bigger problem is the rad outlet (1-9/16"), but I'll find the tubing that I need--one way or the other. It'll happen!


    Nice adapter! Don't think I am going to need it, but what/where did you find it?


    Anyway, the rad is shipping today. I'm trying to get a purchase list of plumbing parts together and intend to head to the store today or tomorrow. I'll let you know what I come up with.....


    Have you connected to your rad yet, or are you still working that out....?

  2. #127
    Xtreme Member
    Join Date
    Nov 2007
    Location
    rockclimbing alone..
    Posts
    373
    Naja002. Your project sounds very interesting. The only reason why I wouldn't have chosen the radiator you picked is connecting tubing. My radiator has slighty larger than 1" inlet and outlet. 1" tubing will fit if heat treated.

    You are bound tu use a reducer somwhere along the line. How are you going to connect 1" tubing to your waterblocks?

    I used a 3/4 male to femal connector screwed to a 3/4x1/2 nipple fitting. Teflon and grease and it will hold. Hope so really...
    Watercooled by:
    ek supreme
    2 iwaki md-30rz in series
    2 Audi tt 44x66cm car radiators....

    The Ultimate Tribute to Radiators...

    Daily:




  3. #128
    Xtreme Addict
    Join Date
    Jul 2006
    Location
    Usa
    Posts
    1,166
    Hi Alex,

    I'll start a thread after I get some pix of everything, etc. I hit Lowes yesterday and they had everything that I needed. Forgot to get some gate valves (2), but I'll pick them up this wkend.

    I picked up 1' of 1-1/2"ID Braided tubing. I'll cut the length to fit, but the heat treatment will get it over the 1-9/16" outlet. I also picked up 1' of 1-1/4"ID tubing that will fit the 1-5/16" inlet. Those tubes both connect to the appropiate barbed adapters (1-1/2", 1-1/4") which thread (both MPT) into 1" pvc pipe (both FPT). The pvc is reduced to 1" at the adapters. Amazingly, Lowes had everything that I needed.

    My only real question at this point is my pump--Mag Drive 9.5. I'm not sure if its strong enough, but the calculator that I used says it will be--except I cannot factor in the rad itself. I bought that particular rad because its copper/brass, triple core (3 rows) and cheap. <---pretty much in that order. It should offer some decent flow for a radiator.

    This is being setup to cool up to 6 PCs. The 1" pvc pipe will run from the rad, pump, 55gal reservoir in the out-building (only a few feet away) into this room (via the floor) to a pvc manifold that will distribute the water to and from each PC. Water takes the path of least resistance, so the gate valves are going to be incorporated in order to tweak (restrict) the flow from 1 PC or another so that all PCs get adequate flow. Make sense?

    The manifold is 1" pvc pipe and the tubing to and from each PC will be 1/2"ID tubing.

    The rad should be here Tues (5/27). Between now and then--I have some work to do and some pix to take.......

    I'll start a thread when I get some pix taken, etc. Kinda feel like I'm hijacking your thread here. Please let me know if you are feeling the same way at all.

    I'm glad you got connected to the rad. That and the pump are probably the hardest part. That is one sexy rad you got there. Looks like it was made for the indoors......

    Now I just have to figure out how I'm going to buy ~60gal of distilled water without raising a bunch of eyebrows......
    Last edited by Naja002; 05-29-2008 at 07:29 AM.

  4. #129
    Xtreme Member
    Join Date
    Nov 2007
    Location
    rockclimbing alone..
    Posts
    373
    Quote Originally Posted by Naja002 View Post
    Hi Alex,

    I'll start a thread after I get some pix of everything, etc. I hit Lowes yesterday and they had everything that I needed. Forgot to get some gate valves (2), but I'll pick them up this wkend.

    I picked up 1' of 1-1/2"ID Braided tubing. I'll cut the length to fit, but the heat treatment will get it over the 1-9/16" outlet. I also picked up 1' of 1-1/4"ID tubing that will fit the 1-5/16" inlet. Those tubes both connect to the appropiate barbed adapters (1-1/2", 1-1/4") which thread (both MPT) into 1" pvc pipe (both FPT). The pvc is reduced to 1" at the adapters. Amazingly, Lowes had everything that I needed.

    My only real question at this point is my pump--Mag Drive 9.5. I'm not sure if its strong enough, but the calculator that I used says it will be--except I cannot factor in the rad itself. I bought that particular rad because its copper/brass, triple core (3 rows) and cheap. <---pretty much in that order. It should offer some decent flow for a radiator.

    This is being setup to cool up to 3 PCs. The 1" pvc pipe will run from the rad, pump, 55gal reservoir in the out-building (only a few feet away) into this room (via the floor) to a pvc manifold that will distribute the water to and from each PC. Water takes the path of least resistance, so the 2 gate valves are going to be incorporated in order to tweak (restrict) the flow from 1 PC or another so that all 3 PCs get adequate flow. Make sense?

    The manifold is 1" pvc pipe and the tubing to and from each PC will be 1/2"ID tubing.

    The rad should be here Tues (5/27). Between now and then--I have some work to do and some pix to take.......

    I'll start a thread when I get some pix taken, etc. Kinda feel like I'm hijacking your thread here. Please let me know if you are feeling the same way at all.

    I'm glad you got connected to the rad. That and the pump are probably the hardest part. That is one sexy rad you got there. Looks like it was made for the indoors......

    Now I just have to figure out how I'm going to buy ~60gal of distilled water without raising a bunch of eyebrows......
    Don't worry! I am actually very happy someone is gaining some benefit from my experience. I would be actually very pleased if we could keep a sort of "shared thread". Any relevant post from the guys here could help us all.

    I actually noticed that your pump is somewhat small considering amount of liquid and pressure loss due to several "characteristics" (length of tubing, ID of the tubing) of your system.
    From what I noticed your radiator is pretty standard and should not be excessively restrictive. Also, if you consider that most pc radiators actually implement flat tubing as opposed to the car radiator type "round" tubing then leaving size aside, it should work well in terms of flow. I am sure your calculations are correct however I personally always try to err on the side of caution. It would be a pity if you got this amazing system working to find out, after some time, that you might want/need a bigger pump. Ebay might help you here...

    keep us posted. As I said I am studying had thus have very limited time. My project will take time to set up and be properly tuned. You are welcome to "hijack" my thread.
    Watercooled by:
    ek supreme
    2 iwaki md-30rz in series
    2 Audi tt 44x66cm car radiators....

    The Ultimate Tribute to Radiators...

    Daily:




  5. #130
    Xtreme Addict
    Join Date
    Jul 2006
    Location
    Usa
    Posts
    1,166
    Ok, taking a break, so here's an update on my end. Plumbing is completed in and out of the blue barrel. Its also completed through the floors of each building and connected. The pump arrived in the mail today (), so I'm going to get the plumbing done on that--today! The only things I'm missing is the rad and the gate valves, so I should be able to complete +90&#37; of the main plumbing. Before I am finished with the main plumbing, I need to figure out how I am going to test/flush/maintain this system. I'll get it sorted out though....no sweat.


    Quote Originally Posted by Alexontherocks View Post
    Don't worry! I am actually very happy someone is gaining some benefit from my experience. I would be actually very pleased if we could keep a sort of "shared thread". Any relevant post from the guys here could help us all.
    Cool. I'll start my own thread and link from here to there and there to here. I think that the more threads available on this car rad subject--the easier it will be for other interested folks to find the info!


    Quote Originally Posted by Alexontherocks View Post
    I actually noticed that your pump is somewhat small considering amount of liquid and pressure loss due to several "characteristics" (length of tubing, ID of the tubing) of your system.
    Flow loss isn't as great as people generally think. Some of the "Reefers" (saltwater aquarium folks aka "reef" keepers) are just as hardcore about what they do as many of the folks here at XS. <--have no doubt about that! I just used this Head Loss Calculator to get a rough idea. Minus the radiator, but with extra elbows, etc thrown into the equation. Here's an example:




    I am expecting to use ~35' of 1" pipe and about 5' of 1" tubing. So, the 40' is fair, except its not factoring in the 4x 1" barbs (1" barb x MPT)--they will definitely offer some restriction. I entered 25 90-elbows, but only expect to use 13. I entered 10' of vertical head, but it will not be over 6.5' max. And just as important--I entered it all on 3/4" pipe--I'm using 1". I still come up with 190gph flow and 1.21psi (rated is 6.5psi). I think it'll work, but there's only one way to find out! I picked it up for $60 shipped, so I should be able to sell it for that, if need be.....

    I keep debating on whether to use 1/2" or 3/8" tubing from the manifold to the PCs. I still need to buy the tubing, so I can go either route. I'll definitely be going the 1/8" wall route (1/2"ID x 3/4" OD or 3/8"ID x 5/8"OD). I've already got the barbs for the 1/2" and wondering if the 3/8" would create too much restriction. Either way, I think the 1" manifold will feed things well enough..... I have some tubing and barbs of both, so I guess I'll just have to check things out before I decide.

    In reference to the head loss calculator: I doubt its 100% spot-on 100% of the time. If any of the fluid dynamics engineers would like to check out its accuracy--I've little doubt that the XS community would be appreciative! But from what I understand--its a very good tool for the planning stage.




    Quote Originally Posted by Alexontherocks View Post
    From what I noticed your radiator is pretty standard and should not be excessively restrictive. Also, if you consider that most pc radiators actually implement flat tubing as opposed to the car radiator type "round" tubing then leaving size aside, it should work well in terms of flow. I am sure your calculations are correct however I personally always try to err on the side of caution. It would be a pity if you got this amazing system working to find out, after some time, that you might want/need a bigger pump. Ebay might help you here...

    Again, I think the pump is going to work, but I was over-joyed to find a copper triple core raditor! The 3 rows not only offer good cooling--but better flow also. I'll have to take a look when it gets here, but I think it'll work work whether the tubing is round or flat. We'll see....



    Quote Originally Posted by Alexontherocks View Post
    keep us posted. As I said I am studying had thus have very limited time. My project will take time to set up and be properly tuned. You are welcome to "hijack" my thread.
    Thanx for Your Support. Wkends are my busy time, so things are working out pretty good actually. I have fairly convenient access to 3 walmarts and Lowes, so I guess I'll hit the WMs this wkend and start picking up 2-3 cases of gal. jugs of distilled water from each!



    Last edited by Naja002; 05-29-2008 at 07:30 AM.

  6. #131
    Chasing After Diety
    Join Date
    Jan 2007
    Location
    Absolutely Speachless :O
    Posts
    11,930
    Quote Originally Posted by KaptCrunch View Post
    think you have 3/4" garden hose with no end, water flowing an you cover your finger over end to about 3/8 opening ......what happends
    super soaker?

    Or water fight.
    Nadeshiko: i7 990 12GB DDR3 eVGA Classified *In Testing... Jealous? *
    Miyuki: W3580 6GB DDR3 P6T-Dlx
    Lind: Dual Gainestown 3.07
    Sammy: Dual Yonah Sossoman cheerleader. *Sammy-> Lind.*

    [12:37] skinnee: quit helping me procrastinate block reviews, you asshat. :p
    [12:38] Naekuh: i love watching u get the firing squad on XS
    Its my fault.. and no im not sorry about it either.

  7. #132
    Xtreme Addict
    Join Date
    Jul 2006
    Location
    Usa
    Posts
    1,166
    Quote Originally Posted by KaptCrunch View Post
    think you have 3/4" garden hose with no end, water flowing an you cover your finger over end to about 3/8 opening ......what happends

    Hi Kapt Crunch,

    I understand what You are saying, but those examples usually assume a better water supply--meaning "household". Household (and industrial/commercial) water supplies normally have much higher pressure (normally ~40psi). The problem here is that my psi source is a small pump (rated 6.5psi). I'm not sure how well my little pump would hold up against the garden hose test....

    But I do understand Your point--and Thank You for tossing it in here! I am no fluid dynamics engineer, so my skills/knowledge/understanding are limited. Just using the surface area of a circle--the 1" pipe should be able to pump more than either 3x the 1/2" or 3/8". But 4x the 1/2" works out just right......1" circle=0.785.....4x 1/2" circles=0.785

    Reasonable entries into the head loss calculator offer a 2.44psi and flow of 464gph/60min=7.73gpm/3PCs= 2.57gpm per PC.


    IF I could maintain that 2.44psi then I realize that the water would just travel faster through the 3/8" tubing. So, my real question would be--under these circumstances--should I expect a reduction in psi/gpm by going with the 3/8" tubing v the 1/2"? Honestly, I really don't know. I would appreciate feedback from anyone that understands this particular point....


    I did seal the 55gal. blue barrel, so in theory this is a closed loop. Also, the pump is drawing water--out--of the barrel....not pushing it into the barrel. So, pressure in the barrel should be negative, not positive. Further helping the seal.

    Any Thoughts.....?
    Last edited by Naja002; 05-22-2008 at 06:14 PM.

  8. #133
    Xtreme Member
    Join Date
    Nov 2007
    Location
    rockclimbing alone..
    Posts
    373
    Quote Originally Posted by KaptCrunch View Post
    think you have 3/4" garden hose with no end, water flowing an you cover your finger over end to about 3/8 opening ......what happends
    unfortunately that sort of solution is necessary. I have adapted a 1" tubing to a 1/2" (12x17) in order to feed my waterblock. Am I in for a surprise as soon as I get my wb hooked up to the tubing?

    Unfortunately there is very little one can do if there is a car radiator envolved. I believe very few actually have 1/2" inlets and outlets. Most have 1" or larger OD so unless I can find a wb supporting 1" tubing then I see no other solution than to reduce tubing somewhere along the line. 3/4 x 3/8 is actually the type of reducer I built (the only feasible solution). However the tubing will be 1"x1/2". TEFLON tape and hoseclamps + silicon are necessary.
    Watercooled by:
    ek supreme
    2 iwaki md-30rz in series
    2 Audi tt 44x66cm car radiators....

    The Ultimate Tribute to Radiators...

    Daily:




  9. #134
    Xtreme X.I.P.
    Join Date
    Jun 2007
    Location
    Bend, Oregon
    Posts
    5,693
    The bigger tubing is good, although the roughness added by the metal spring will add a little friction. I'd probably just run the larger tubing until you made it to the exterior of your computer case, then reduce it down to something that's convenient to run in your computer.

    Friction losses are given probably more attention than they deserve in tubing and fitting (although some fittings are pretty bad), as long as you keep that stuff to a minimum it's usually insignificant.
    As long as you have a strong enoug pump to overcome filling the system (for example you don't want to run a pond pump with 4 feet of head and expect to fill a system with 6' of height difference) you should be fine. Once the loop is full that static pressure that it has to overcome is removed by the water coming back down the other side.

    Anyhow, my 2c.

  10. #135
    Xtreme Member
    Join Date
    Nov 2007
    Location
    rockclimbing alone..
    Posts
    373
    Quote Originally Posted by Martinm210 View Post
    The bigger tubing is good, although the roughness added by the metal spring will add a little friction. I'd probably just run the larger tubing until you made it to the exterior of your computer case, then reduce it down to something that's convenient to run in your computer.
    my idea exactly. One small edit: the spring is embedded in the tubing. The plastic is smooth on the inside. Thanks for the input!
    Watercooled by:
    ek supreme
    2 iwaki md-30rz in series
    2 Audi tt 44x66cm car radiators....

    The Ultimate Tribute to Radiators...

    Daily:




  11. #136
    Xtreme Member
    Join Date
    Nov 2007
    Location
    rockclimbing alone..
    Posts
    373
    just one more problem....will the pump suffer from having such a variance in tubing diameter?
    Watercooled by:
    ek supreme
    2 iwaki md-30rz in series
    2 Audi tt 44x66cm car radiators....

    The Ultimate Tribute to Radiators...

    Daily:




  12. #137
    Xtreme Addict
    Join Date
    Jul 2006
    Location
    Usa
    Posts
    1,166
    Houston--we have Flow!


    Well, for right now we do!

    Still waiting on the rad which will be here tomorrow. PCs are not hooked up. But the barrel, pump, and plumbing are pumping from one building to the other--all setup, filled and moving water.

    I currently have the system filled with my tap water to flush it out. I put drains at the lowest point on each line (to and from) in order to be able to drain the system. The barrel is detachable. I'm still debating on whether I want to buy distilled water or a new membrane for my RODI system.

    Right now, I am just going to let it run and flush itself. Debris should flush into the barrel. Tomorrow I will hook up the rad and run it. Then start putting a shroud around it. Not likely that I am going to use the car rad fans. I think 1 or 2 of the 9" floor fans will be enough to create the necessary air-flow. ~63w each on high, ~40w on low. 120v and can easily be connected to a timer.

    Its probably going to be a week or 2 before I can get the PCs incorporated into the system. I ordered some stuff today, and I still need to order the tubing. I'm building an open bench-top multi-PC case. Hopefully that will be done by the time the other stuff gets here.

    The hard part is pretty much done.


    Thank You, Martin, for the input. Pretty much clarifies what I was thinking. A closed loop is different then just trying to pump straight vertical head. I seem to have plenty of pressure at the moment without the rad. The gate valves to the PCs are closed and the manifold by-pass (1") is wide open. Yet I still have some tygon tubing doing a bit of bouncing (1/2" barb return to 1/2" barb inflow--closed gate valve).

    I still need to run full-time power to the building for the pump and fan(s). I picked up some of the stuff the other day, but that is kinda/sorta turning into a project of it own...... I'll git-r-done.......

    I'm not seeing any issues coming up. But we'll see.....
    Last edited by Naja002; 05-26-2008 at 09:43 AM.

  13. #138
    Xtreme Member
    Join Date
    Nov 2007
    Location
    rockclimbing alone..
    Posts
    373
    Great! Make sure you flush everything with pure water at the end. Milan (where I live) has such a mineral rich tap water that I have already seen some sign of crystal formation on the inside of the pump head.

    Anyway I have built my relay switch. Not much of an update but it looks very good. Encased in a black plastic box it al so has two leds: blu for correct functioning and red if by any chance any of the connections (12v or pump feeding line) fail.

    One question though: What if I hook up the relay to one of my fan conectors of my motherboard? The switch absorbs 80 milli amps and requires 12v to activate. This means that if I were to hook it up to the mobo I would be able to switch the pump off through speedfan by adjusting the speed of "fan 3" (were the realy will be hooked at) to "0" correct?
    Last edited by Alexontherocks; 05-26-2008 at 10:52 PM.
    Watercooled by:
    ek supreme
    2 iwaki md-30rz in series
    2 Audi tt 44x66cm car radiators....

    The Ultimate Tribute to Radiators...

    Daily:




  14. #139
    Xtreme Member
    Join Date
    Nov 2007
    Location
    rockclimbing alone..
    Posts
    373
    Sorry to double post but I have a small update on my setup and a question:

    I have received my ek supreme plexy top. Looks sweet! I have not purchased the barbs and here is what I came up with:



    Industrial barbs with teflon and oring. You can see the teflon through the plexy.

    I have a question though. I tried hooking everything up and there is flow but it is very modest! if I hold up (in the bathtub) the tube coming out from the ek supreme I get a steady flow of approximetaly 40cm before the water falls back in the tub. Is this normal? Is this block that restrictive? Without the block the water coming from the pump outlet would move (even if submerged) the whole volume of water in the tub. Something more like a jacuzzi rather than a normal pump. Ideas?

    P.s. comments on barbs are welcome!
    Watercooled by:
    ek supreme
    2 iwaki md-30rz in series
    2 Audi tt 44x66cm car radiators....

    The Ultimate Tribute to Radiators...

    Daily:




  15. #140
    Xtreme Addict
    Join Date
    Oct 2003
    Location
    USA /okla
    Posts
    2,103
    should have plenty of hose clamping area to work with
    i7 6700K @4.8 ghz
    XSPC RayStorm (very nice block)
    Z170 Sabertooh ,, 32GB- Gskill (15-15-15-36 @3600 mhz) 1:1
    XFX-7970 with Swiftech Komodo nickel block
    Water Cooling - MO-RA3 Pro with 4 Silverstone 180mm @ 700 rpm, Twin Vario mcp-655 pumps
    Samsung 850-1TB SSD,, OCZ ZX-1250W (powerfull and silent)
    Crossfire 30" decent monitor for IPS too bad SED tech died

    Docsis2.0 Docsis3.0

    -- People who reject the idea that "government has a responsibility to reduce income inequality" give an average of four times more than people who accept that proposition.

  16. #141
    Xtreme Member
    Join Date
    Nov 2007
    Location
    rockclimbing alone..
    Posts
    373
    Quote Originally Posted by iboomalot View Post
    should have plenty of hose clamping area to work with
    True! I was particularly concerned with pressure near motherboard and charged components so I chose barbs with ample possibility of Xtreme clamping.

    Not sure how to interpret the substancial flow loss. Is such a drastic reduction normal when using a ek supreme?

    spunds about right if I use martin's spreadsheet and choose an iwaki as a refernce (strongest pump an still not as strong as mine)

    awaiting your opinions...
    Watercooled by:
    ek supreme
    2 iwaki md-30rz in series
    2 Audi tt 44x66cm car radiators....

    The Ultimate Tribute to Radiators...

    Daily:




  17. #142
    Xtreme Addict
    Join Date
    Jul 2006
    Location
    Usa
    Posts
    1,166
    Quote Originally Posted by Alexontherocks View Post
    just one more problem....will the pump suffer from having such a variance in tubing diameter?
    Quote Originally Posted by Alexontherocks View Post
    Sorry to double post but I have a small update on my setup and a question:

    I have received my ek supreme plexy top. Looks sweet! I have not purchased the barbs and here is what I came up with:



    Industrial barbs with teflon and oring. You can see the teflon through the plexy.

    I have a question though. I tried hooking everything up and there is flow but it is very modest! if I hold up (in the bathtub) the tube coming out from the ek supreme I get a steady flow of approximetaly 40cm before the water falls back in the tub. Is this normal? Is this block that restrictive? Without the block the water coming from the pump outlet would move (even if submerged) the whole volume of water in the tub. Something more like a jacuzzi rather than a normal pump. Ideas?

    P.s. comments on barbs are welcome!
    Hi Alex,

    1 Question that I have had is whether or not your pump is too powerful...!?!? As in: Waaaay too powerful. I'm wondering also if the acrylic top/o-ring is going to hold over the long haul.

    10m (~33Ft) of Head and 8400LPH (~2220GPH) is more than overkill. Are you trying to send all of that through just the 1 block?

    if I hold up (in the bathtub) the tube coming out from the ek supreme I get a steady flow of approximetaly 40cm before the water falls back in the tub. Is this normal? Is this block that restrictive?
    Kind of hard to explain, but your pump probably isn't able to function under those circumstances--its just too powerful. I'd say you are wasting a lot of electricity and going to burn out the pump. I can't seem to get the words together to try to explain what I know, but I've had this instinctive feeling for a while now. Maybe someone else will come along and offer an explanation, or maybe the words will come to me later.

    Just imagine hooking up that block directly to the pump: 4" of tubing then the adapter down to 1ft of 1/2ID, attached to the block......What would you expect? I would expect disaster in 1 form or another. Tubing popping off, water squirting out from the acrylic top/o-ring......Something bad! 10m head and +2000gph is more than a lot! Much more...... That takes quite a bit of psi for a pump. I don't think that these blocks are really made for that kind of pressure. Even if the setup held--initially--I would lay awake at night over the long term worrying about it.

    Again, hard to explain, but the 1/2"ID tubing and the block may be so restrictive--in comparison to the pumps ability--that the pump may not even really be able to get a decent start (so-to-speak) before its almost completely restricted. If the plumbing doesn't give....sooner or later: the pump will.... Hope that makes sense!

    I have an update on my setup. I'll post it after while.....

  18. #143
    Xtreme Member
    Join Date
    Nov 2007
    Location
    rockclimbing alone..
    Posts
    373
    Quote Originally Posted by Naja002 View Post
    Hi Alex,

    1 Question that I have had is whether or not your pump is too powerful...!?!? As in: Waaaay too powerful. I'm wondering also if the acrylic top/o-ring is going to hold over the long haul.

    10m (~33Ft) of Head and 8400LPH (~2220GPH) is more than overkill. Are you trying to send all of that through just the 1 block?



    Kind of hard to explain, but your pump probably isn't able to function under those circumstances--its just too powerful. I'd say you are wasting a lot of electricity and going to burn out the pump. I can't seem to get the words together to try to explain what I know, but I've had this instinctive feeling for a while now. Maybe someone else will come along and offer an explanation, or maybe the words will come to me later.

    Just imagine hooking up that block directly to the pump: 4" of tubing then the adapter down to 1ft of 1/2ID, attached to the block......What would you expect? I would expect disaster in 1 form or another. Tubing popping off, water squirting out from the acrylic top/o-ring......Something bad! 10m head and +2000gph is more than a lot! Much more...... That takes quite a bit of psi for a pump. I don't think that these blocks are really made for that kind of pressure. Even if the setup held--initially--I would lay awake at night over the long term worrying about it.

    Again, hard to explain, but the 1/2"ID tubing and the block may be so restrictive--in comparison to the pumps ability--that the pump may not even really be able to get a decent start (so-to-speak) before its almost completely restricted. If the plumbing doesn't give....sooner or later: the pump will.... Hope that makes sense!

    I have an update on my setup. I'll post it after while.....
    I would imagine there is truth in what you say but let me point out (I have very little expertise in pump and/or plumbing so everything will sound very empirical) that an iwaki rd30 can generate at 24v the same pressure (almost if not slightly more than 15 psi) I am quite certain my pump does not exceed this value.

    When I tried everything in the tub I set the pump as it will function in real life: 1" suction tube (1 metre) from the tub - pump - 40cm of 1" tube - reducer and 1 metre of 1/2 tubing - ek supreme.

    I also tried hooking the ek supreme right after the outlet using a single piece of 30 cm 1/2" tubing. The result is identical. What I can say is that I may have mixed up outlet and inlet on the ek supreme!

    Anyhow my pump is a simple centrifugal circulation pump and as far as idraulics are concerned it should perform more or less like a full powered iwaki.

    Granted the power requirements are enormous and let me tell you that the efficieny of the pump, judging by the heat output, is quite low but nontheless I really can't understand why this kind of pump would cause havock in any well built system. Grimreaperguy stated he uses a 30m (height) 90lpm pump and has no problem what so ever. If anything he has a pressure load of just about 3 times what I would ever achieve....

    I will use silicon for every barb/reducer/poin of contact and use insulating waterproof balck tape on top of that. Industrial (long) barbs will let me use multiple clamps on the ek supreme.

    We will see anyway how thing turn out...
    Watercooled by:
    ek supreme
    2 iwaki md-30rz in series
    2 Audi tt 44x66cm car radiators....

    The Ultimate Tribute to Radiators...

    Daily:




  19. #144
    Xtreme Addict
    Join Date
    Oct 2003
    Location
    USA /okla
    Posts
    2,103
    only problem I see is a point of diminshing returns

    as flow increases so does pressure

    main problem I can see is heat from a pump that size offsetting what little extra flow you will get.


    once you hit 3gal/min your gain in heat transfer at 6gal/min will not be much better and the extra heat generated by the pump will be more than the gain in flow.

    I know the RAD should be able to sluff off the heat but you are still adding alot of heat to the overall system with a pump that large.

    if you own the pump then use it but Iam going to use a MD-20 rlt myself with my auto Rad setup
    i7 6700K @4.8 ghz
    XSPC RayStorm (very nice block)
    Z170 Sabertooh ,, 32GB- Gskill (15-15-15-36 @3600 mhz) 1:1
    XFX-7970 with Swiftech Komodo nickel block
    Water Cooling - MO-RA3 Pro with 4 Silverstone 180mm @ 700 rpm, Twin Vario mcp-655 pumps
    Samsung 850-1TB SSD,, OCZ ZX-1250W (powerfull and silent)
    Crossfire 30" decent monitor for IPS too bad SED tech died

    Docsis2.0 Docsis3.0

    -- People who reject the idea that "government has a responsibility to reduce income inequality" give an average of four times more than people who accept that proposition.

  20. #145
    Xtreme Member
    Join Date
    Nov 2007
    Location
    rockclimbing alone..
    Posts
    373
    Quote Originally Posted by iboomalot View Post
    only problem I see is a point of diminshing returns

    as flow increases so does pressure

    main problem I can see is heat from a pump that size offsetting what little extra flow you will get.


    once you hit 3gal/min your gain in heat transfer at 6gal/min will not be much better and the extra heat generated by the pump will be more than the gain in flow.

    I know the RAD should be able to sluff off the heat but you are still adding alot of heat to the overall system with a pump that large.

    if you own the pump then use it but Iam going to use a MD-20 rlt myself with my auto Rad setup
    This is also very true but let me point out that my pump is divided into 2 pieces. The electric engine (coils) is separated from the circulation area (the head of the pump) as can be seen in this picture: http://www.xtremesystems.org/forums/...&postcount=117

    heatdump can still occur but it would have to occur across the limited diametre of the impeller shaft.
    Watercooled by:
    ek supreme
    2 iwaki md-30rz in series
    2 Audi tt 44x66cm car radiators....

    The Ultimate Tribute to Radiators...

    Daily:




  21. #146
    Xtreme Addict
    Join Date
    Oct 2003
    Location
    USA /okla
    Posts
    2,103
    thats a tim taylor pump for sure
    i7 6700K @4.8 ghz
    XSPC RayStorm (very nice block)
    Z170 Sabertooh ,, 32GB- Gskill (15-15-15-36 @3600 mhz) 1:1
    XFX-7970 with Swiftech Komodo nickel block
    Water Cooling - MO-RA3 Pro with 4 Silverstone 180mm @ 700 rpm, Twin Vario mcp-655 pumps
    Samsung 850-1TB SSD,, OCZ ZX-1250W (powerfull and silent)
    Crossfire 30" decent monitor for IPS too bad SED tech died

    Docsis2.0 Docsis3.0

    -- People who reject the idea that "government has a responsibility to reduce income inequality" give an average of four times more than people who accept that proposition.

  22. #147
    Xtreme Addict
    Join Date
    Jul 2006
    Location
    Usa
    Posts
    1,166
    Hi Alex,

    Honestly, I think we're both getting into a realm that we don't know enough about to discuss/debate/decide what's going on. All I really know is from my past experiences dealing with pumps. Hopefully, someone else will come along and help explain what's going on.....

    A quick update on my setup:

    The car rad arrived yesterday and I have been working my butt off to get stuff done. Basically, everything is done (no PCs involved yet)--with 3 minor issues:

    1) I need a frickin' radiator cap! What pisses me off is that I went to walmart and the hardware store today--forgot all about stopping at the auto parts store....errrrrr


    (Autozone has one in stock--$4.99 )

    2) The caps for the blue barrel are leaking again where I drilled and siliconed. Not a big deal when the system is running, but during a long power outage--there will be some leakage (~3gals). I'll have to pick up some more caps at work and come up with a new plan for sealing them.

    3) Have to figure out a way to plug the radiator "overflow" vent. Not a big issue, but can't run the system until its done.


    With 1 & 3 completed--I'll be able to run the system, until I can get #2 done. Either way, right now, I'm tired. I've taken lot's of pix, so I'll see about putting a new thread together before long.

    Best I can tell ATM is that I will still have plenty of flow. Just can't run things long enough right now to really check it out.


    I have a Q9450 coming tomorrow, the PC tubing and some other stuff. 2x UPS and 1X DHL. I may run out and get the rad cap

  23. #148
    Xtreme Member
    Join Date
    Nov 2007
    Location
    rockclimbing alone..
    Posts
    373
    Quote Originally Posted by iboomalot View Post
    thats a tim taylor pump for sure
    I am not sure what you mean with tim taylor...

    Quote Originally Posted by Naja002 View Post
    Hi Alex,

    Honestly, I think we're both getting into a realm that we don't know enough about to discuss/debate/decide what's going on. All I really know is from my past experiences dealing with pumps. Hopefully, someone else will come along and help explain what's going on.....

    A quick update on my setup:

    The car rad arrived yesterday and I have been working my butt off to get stuff done. Basically, everything is done (no PCs involved yet)--with 3 minor issues:

    1) I need a frickin' radiator cap! What pisses me off is that I went to walmart and the hardware store today--forgot all about stopping at the auto parts store....errrrrr


    (Autozone has one in stock--$4.99 )

    2) The caps for the blue barrel are leaking again where I drilled and siliconed. Not a big deal when the system is running, but during a long power outage--there will be some leakage (~3gals). I'll have to pick up some more caps at work and come up with a new plan for sealing them.

    3) Have to figure out a way to plug the radiator "overflow" vent. Not a big issue, but can't run the system until its done.


    With 1 & 3 completed--I'll be able to run the system, until I can get #2 done. Either way, right now, I'm tired. I've taken lot's of pix, so I'll see about putting a new thread together before long.

    Best I can tell ATM is that I will still have plenty of flow. Just can't run things long enough right now to really check it out.


    I have a Q9450 coming tomorrow, the PC tubing and some other stuff. 2x UPS and 1X DHL. I may run out and get the rad cap
    You are probably right....I hope someone will come by and shed some light on the subject. This may prove useful for anyone envolved in projects featuring a powerful pump.
    Watercooled by:
    ek supreme
    2 iwaki md-30rz in series
    2 Audi tt 44x66cm car radiators....

    The Ultimate Tribute to Radiators...

    Daily:




  24. #149
    Xtreme Addict
    Join Date
    Oct 2003
    Location
    USA /okla
    Posts
    2,103
    forgot you aren't in the USA

    Tim "the toolman" Taylor is a person played on a CitCom here in USA. He takes ordinary tools or products and makes them more manly by beefing them up

    example would be fitting a Jet engine to a lawn mover to soup it up.


    I was saying that you have a "manly" pump

    might look these over

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AV2MehkFcTw

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tY5WxDqggbs
    Last edited by iboomalot; 05-29-2008 at 03:50 AM.
    i7 6700K @4.8 ghz
    XSPC RayStorm (very nice block)
    Z170 Sabertooh ,, 32GB- Gskill (15-15-15-36 @3600 mhz) 1:1
    XFX-7970 with Swiftech Komodo nickel block
    Water Cooling - MO-RA3 Pro with 4 Silverstone 180mm @ 700 rpm, Twin Vario mcp-655 pumps
    Samsung 850-1TB SSD,, OCZ ZX-1250W (powerfull and silent)
    Crossfire 30" decent monitor for IPS too bad SED tech died

    Docsis2.0 Docsis3.0

    -- People who reject the idea that "government has a responsibility to reduce income inequality" give an average of four times more than people who accept that proposition.

  25. #150
    Xtreme Addict
    Join Date
    Jul 2006
    Location
    Usa
    Posts
    1,166
    Houston.....the rad is installed and we have flow!

    Went and got the Radiator cap. I've had an on-going problem getting the pump primed (may fix the situation later), so I added a PVC "access" Tee.

    There's definitely flow. The 1/2" tubing (attached to the manifold)that's closed off on one end is still bouncing. Life is good. Waiting on UPS and DHL now.

    Not sure how much more I'll get done today. Work week starting in the early AM. Expecting to be "distracted" after UPS and DHL get here. Still need to get some other non-pc stuff done too.

    Also, not sure what I was thinking: I don't expect any "Over-heating" with this setup, so the rad cap blocks the over-flow port----DUH! ---Sometimes it takes me a minute to catch up!
    Last edited by Naja002; 05-29-2008 at 07:20 AM.

Page 6 of 7 FirstFirst ... 34567 LastLast

Bookmarks

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •