Do you have the PCI-e slots at 4x/NA? If so one of the LAN won't work. Have to set it to 1x 1x to get both working.
EDIT: Hope the RMA through MBpro works out for you. I try to use DFI's RMA as a last resort. They've had my P965-S for over 2 weeks and have yet to update me.
Also, anyone know a reliable way to test memory on this board? Memtest 1.70 doesn't seem to work right and I'm not as trustful of Memtest for Windows.
Bookmarks