So let me get this straight. Anand had a spreadsheet error, which skewed the results significantly and made Nehalem looks much better relatively in the graph?

I find it hard to trust the entire set of tests now, that is very very sloppy. What other tests results are wrong? And does Anand have the Nahelem rig permanently in his possession? He was able to rerun some tests right away.

used data from the wrong column (first run data vs. average run data) for Cinebench
Why would the first run be so vastly different?