Maybe at release. But not after the crossfire improvements in drivers released since then. I have been using a 5970 since shortly after release and it has improved substantially. In games that scale properly across 2 gpus and aren't cpu bound a 5970 is about 45-65% faster then a 5870. The average was dragged down by many games without proper 5970 support in the driver, but many were added in more recent drivers. Crossfire/SLI scaling isn't great, but it isn't 40% with proper profiles either.
That's why it's important to pay attention to driver version used in reviews. Some of the new fermi reviews will doubtlessly use old data for the rest of the cards. That doesn't really give you a picture of the reality of the marketplace now.
Bookmarks