Results 1 to 25 of 55

Thread: ATI Radeon HD 5950 = Radeon HD 5870 With Six DisplayPort Connections

Hybrid View

  1. #1
    Xtreme Addict
    Join Date
    Jan 2008
    Posts
    1,463
    689D could be hemlock pro, since it's looking like 689c is hemlock xt. BUT, who says that gpuz read that bios and correctly identified any of the following:
    689C dev id, 1600sp shader count, 725/1000 core/mem clocks.

    IMO 689C will come with a full-cover cooling shroud that looks like the 5870 & 5850, be hemlock XT, have 2gb total memory, core clock of somewhere between 850-950mhz, and memory of around 1200-1250. 689D dev id will be 5950, 1440sp shader x 2, have a duo-orb w/ partial shroud style cooling, be hemlock Pro, 2gb memory @ 725/1000.
    IMO, 5870 Six will have a different dev id and a different product name.

    People make the argument that they had to lower clocks of the memory and core to reduce the (completely rumored) 375w tdp to < 300w. But clockspeeds don't make anywhere near the impact on power draw that memory & core voltages do. Meh, no one is sure. I'm still hoping for 3 different parts, a 5970, 5950, and 5870six.

    Assume there is only one X2, the 5970, and it's clocked at 725/1000. People will be OCing that sucker to 1050/1300 anyway.

    edit: hey blob, where did you hear Nov. 9th as release date? Last i heard was Nov. 19th, but it was Oct. 23rd before that, so no telling.
    Last edited by jaredpace; 11-03-2009 at 11:59 AM.
    Bring... bring the amber lamps.
    [SIGPIC][/SIGPIC]

  2. #2
    Registered User
    Join Date
    Aug 2009
    Posts
    32
    Quote Originally Posted by jaredpace View Post
    689D could be hemlock pro, since it's looking like 689c is hemlock xt. BUT, who says that gpuz read that bios and correctly identified any of the following:
    689C dev id, 1600sp shader count, 725/1000 core/mem clocks.
    GPU-Z reads the device id correctly. Shadercount/ROP's are derived from a database. Core/mem freq i don't know

    IMO 689C will come with a full-cover cooling shroud that looks like the 5870 & 5850, be hemlock XT, have 2gb total memory, core clock of somewhere between 850-950mhz, and memory of around 1200-1250. 689D dev id will be 5950, 1440sp shader x 2, have a duo-orb w/ partial shroud style cooling, be hemlock Pro, 2gb memory @ 725/1000.
    IMO, 5870 Six will have a different dev id and a different product name.
    Like this?


    The name for the 5870 six = HD5870 Eyefinity(6) Edition

    People make the argument that they had to lower clocks of the memory and core to reduce the (completely rumored) 375w tdp to < 300w. But clockspeeds don't make anywhere near the impact on power draw that memory & core voltages do. Meh, no one is sure. I'm still hoping for 3 different parts, a 5970, 5950, and 5870six.
    The card used here has the initial cooler which was also seen on the first hemlock pictures on chiphell. I guess it's an early engineering sample so core and mem speeds are not final.

    edit: hey blob, where did you hear Nov. 9th as release date? Last i heard was Nov. 19th, but it was Oct. 23rd before that, so no telling.
    link

  3. #3
    Xtreme Addict
    Join Date
    Jan 2008
    Posts
    1,463
    Quote Originally Posted by blob View Post
    GPU-Z reads the device id correctly. Shadercount/ROP's are derived from a database. Core/mem freq i don't know



    Like this?


    The name for the 5870 six = HD5870 Eyefinity(6) Edition


    The card used here has the initial cooler which was also seen on the first hemlock pictures on chiphell. I guess it's an early engineering sample so core and mem speeds are not final.


    link
    Yah I agree, that image in your picture is a final 5970

    the initial cooler in the abt, tipidpc, hwc, and chiphell photos is the ES design. By November 09 on tweakers i think CJ means November 2009 cause the other estimates say Q1 10 and Q2 10 where the '10' refers to the year. But hopefully it is November 9th!

    Gpuz reads the clocks from the card, you know if you oc and reopen the util, it reads the new clocks accurately. You're right about reading shader count from a DB which means Wizzard has set 689C as Hemlock XT

    Still no telling on exactly what the 5950 will be, and people seem to be divided over it. I agree the six miniDP 5870 will be called the eyefinity6 edition.

    If there is no 5950, what do you think the Duo-orb card is in the HWC pics?
    Bring... bring the amber lamps.
    [SIGPIC][/SIGPIC]

  4. #4
    Xtreme Addict
    Join Date
    Jul 2007
    Location
    Alberta, Canada
    Posts
    1,264
    I do believe there will be a 5950 but I don't see how it could be a hemlock part unless it is at 499 and the 5970 is at 549-599 as there is no room price wise on the current line up to have both a 5950/70 and keep the top model at $499. However I don't see AMD setting an MSRP higher than $499 USD for their top part in the current market. Sure they *could* do it as there is no competition but as far as would they is another story all together.

    Yes I know we have the marketing slide showing hemlock as high end at < $499 but it still leaves us with the question of "What in the hell is the 5950?"

    Now to me this would be feasible but I still don't see it happening so this is strictly for kicks. I believe it could be possible to have a 2880SP 5950 card at slightly lower clocks than the 3200SP 5970. Again though my mentioned pricing information would have to apply to fit it in. The line up (on a scale of price / performance ) would clearly be 5750 -> 5770 -> 5850 -> 5870 -> 5870 eyefinity ( assumed to be 2GB to accommodate the high resolutions ) -> 5950 -> 5970 ( I don't expect either to be 2x2048vram but 2x1024 just like the previous 4870x2 )

    Now unless that duo orb type cooler was strictly an ES for 5970 ( which I don't know if that was the ES cooler you are meaning? ) there should still be the possibility of a 5950. However I don't agree that we need one. If AIBs want to do one, all the power to them but personally I don't see it happening again for market placement / price issues.
    Feedanator 7.0
    CASE:R5|PSU:850G2|CPU:i7 6850K|MB:x99 Ultra|RAM:8x4 2666|GPU:980TI|SSD:BPX256/Evo500|SOUND:2i4/HS8
    LCD:XB271HU|OS:Win10|INPUT:G900/K70 |HS/F:H115i

  5. #5
    Registered User
    Join Date
    Aug 2009
    Posts
    32
    Quote Originally Posted by jaredpace View Post
    By November 09 on tweakers i think CJ means November 2009 cause the other estimates say Q1 10 and Q2 10 where the '10' refers to the year. But hopefully it is November 9th!
    You're right, my mistake. It's november 2009, no specific date mentioned.

    If there is no 5950, what do you think the Duo-orb card is in the HWC pics?
    I agree with HWC:
    "We can be fairly cetain that this is not the ATI OEM spec, but rather a particular manufacturer’s unique cooling option"

    Up to now the names HD5970 and HD5950 aren't mentioned bij AMD/ATI (please correct me if i'm wrong). AMD/ATI uses 5900 series.
    We know there is a Hemlock XT
    We know there are 2 device id's for the 5900 series.
    I think it would make sense if the second 5900 would be a hemlock XT eyefinity (you will need all the graphic power you can get to drive 6 displays).
    A comment made by CJ would/could point in that direction.
    He made a comment about hemlock xt pricing:
    Hemlock xt would be below 500$ because there was an other unannounced product in that price range
    Last edited by blob; 11-04-2009 at 12:39 AM.

  6. #6
    Xtreme Addict
    Join Date
    Jan 2008
    Posts
    1,463
    Quote Originally Posted by blob View Post
    I think it would make sense if the second 5900 would be a hemlock XT eyefinity (you will need all the graphic power you can get to drive 6 displays).
    A comment made by CJ would/could point in that direction.
    Eyefinity six has only 1 gpu with 2GB video memory and six mini-DP, Hemlock has two GPU with dual DVI-D and 1 mini-DP for a total of 3 outputs. IMO the eyefinity6 is of a different series or a model all its own, and 689C and 689C are both 5900/Hemlock.

    Eyefinity6:


    5900:
    Bring... bring the amber lamps.
    [SIGPIC][/SIGPIC]

  7. #7
    Registered User
    Join Date
    Aug 2009
    Posts
    32
    The eyefinity pictures floating around on the net are indeed a singlecore model.

    Apparently every HD5XXX core is capable of driving 6 displays
    Cypress:




    Juniper:


    So the only differance should be in the PCB design

    I think eyefinity is more like the old ATI's all in wonder, so I think there will be several HD5XXX eyefinity models

    For instance:
    59X0 (Hemlock) eyefinity
    59X0 (Hemlock)
    5870 (Cypress) eyefinity
    5870 (Cypress)
    5850 (Cypress)
    5770 (Juniper)
    5750 (Juniper)
    54X0 (Cedar) eyefinity
    54X0 (Cedar)
    Last edited by blob; 11-04-2009 at 03:05 AM.

  8. #8
    Xtreme Member
    Join Date
    Dec 2008
    Location
    Sweden
    Posts
    450
    It has been stated all along that all Evergreen could run up to 6 displays, the only problem being number of ports on the cards.

    I'm getting the feeling that we might not see the Hemlock XT surface first but the 5950 with dual 5850s and the 725/1000 clock that has been floating around. Why? Because ATI wants something to launch when Fermi is launching even though the 5950 should beat it also. It has also a lot of other pro's like giving time for the other cards to get a slight price drop before releasing 5970, more time to build up stock, more time for driver development and so on.

Bookmarks

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •