Mushkin VS Corshair

[Vatos_locos]

ok somebody give me some help here
i want some 2x2 Gb kit and i have a dilemma on those two
http://www.plaisio.gr/product.aspx?c...roduct=1113283 and http://www.plaisio.gr/product.aspx?p...9977727&page=5
prise is the same so witch one of those two clocks better ?

[zsamz_]

if you can find mushkin redline pc2-8000 get it
its cheaper and as good

[18 is # 1]

Both use Powerchips and are probably comparable. Do which ever is cheaper.

[Vatos_locos]

redlines here cost 19€ less than the Xp's so 19€ more for chips that they are 66Mhz binned Higher is not a problem
and both kits cost 119 € so i think i'am going for the Xp's but i found those too :/ http://www.plaisio.gr/product.aspx?p...727&catalog=20
4 of them cost 100€ but they are going to be 4 sticks then :/

[zsamz_]

redlines here cost 19€ less than the Xp's so 19€ more for chips that they are 66Mhz binned Higher is not a problem
and both kits cost 119 € so i think i'am going for the Xp's but i found those too :/ http://www.plaisio.gr/product.aspx?p...727&catalog=20
4 of them cost 100€ but they are going to be 4 sticks then :/

i have yet to see redline to do less than pc-8500 speeds
and those cellshock must be lowbin d9gmh you better off getting high binned for 10€ more

[Vatos_locos]

i'am sorry but my English are not so good so i didn't understand the think for the redline's
as for the cellshock's on friend of mine got 2 of them and they stopped @ 1210Mhz
but lets forget the cellsock's should i go for the Mushkin kit ?

[zsamz_]

any d9gmh will get 1200 with enough voltage lol but not all will last long
yes get the mushkin redline or xp2 you be happy

[Vatos_locos]

oh i know for the D9Gmh now i have on kit of Team's PC9600 i thing i will go for the Corsair most of the people here that have them can get 1180 at least stable with 2.0 2.1 Volt and some can even hit 1200 stable with 2.1 :/

[MGreg]

+1 for redlines.

Reaching 1200Mhz from a 2x2GB is gonna depend highly on the board.
I wouldn't buy a 2x2GB to hit 1200Mhz though, even if it has been done, doesn't mean the batch you'll be buying will.

[Vatos_locos]

sure it wont be defiantly that the mem's will hit 600mhz but as i see here in greece the stats for the corsairs are better :/

[andressergio]

Vatos

Best I can do on my Old Asus P5K deluxe P35 board is Mushkin Ascent 2x2GB is 1141 CL5 om 2,15 wich i like it very much...See my sig

Cheers
Sergio

[Vatos_locos]

thanks man i think those kit can do the same Mhz but the corsair kit with the same price comes with the dominator airflow so i think i'am going for them :p

[zsamz_]

the lucky ones that got 1200 were on redline
corsair would be a good choice too

[Vatos_locos]

will see i'am waiting i thing this Monday i will have the corsair kit i will post some results

[18 is # 1]

Vatos

Best I can do on my Old Asus P5K deluxe P35 board is Mushkin Ascent 2x2GB is 1141 CL5 om 2,15 wich i like it very much...See my sig

Cheers
Sergio

My Ascent 6400s did 1115MHz.

[Vatos_locos]

tomorrow i'm going to bye the corsair kit so this week i will post some results

[EnJoY]

tomorrow i'm going to bye the corshair kit so this week i will post some results

It's Corsair.

[Vatos_locos]

lol i 'am sorry

Corsair Corsair Corsair Corsair Corsair Corsair Corsair Corsair Corsair
ok now ?

[Vatos_locos]

hi i got the mem's and i booted @ 476Mhz 5-4-4-12 with 1.9 Volt stable
max Mhz i could reach was 556Mhz wit 2.1 i will try more but my cpu is not god for overclocking
Q9450 and it maxes @ 3800Mhz :/
nice mems i will try for more tomorrow
some bandwidth tests here

1.9Volt


2Volt


2.1Volt

[18 is # 1]

It's Corsair.

I thought he was describing the mouse avatar.

[-n7-]

hi i got the mem's and i booted @ 476Mhz 5-4-4-12 with 1.9 Volt stable
max Mhz i could reach was 556Mhz wit 2.1 i will try more but my cpu is not god for overclocking
Q9450 and it maxes @ 3800Mhz :/
nice mems i will try for more tomorrow

Nice.

But take CPU out of equation; i'm interested in max 5-5-5 speed.

Run lower CPU 2:3 or 5:8 ratio for that

BTW what kit did you buy?

[Vatos_locos]

i will give it a try n7 in one ore two days i'am curious myself to see the max speeds since most of the guys that got this kit here in Greece were able to hit 1100-1180 at least
i got the corsair kit
and i will try to find one E8600 to see the max bandwidth of the mem's with higher Fsb

[Vatos_locos]

those speeds i managed yesterday rock stable i will try more today and i will update but i think that the cant go more than 1100Mhz they can go up to 1000Mhz with 1.9 Volt this is good because they don't even need the Fan on them they are cool enough more later tomorrow

[Ket]

I used to do stuff for Mushkin so know a good deal about the internal workings, without question the quality and performance of Mushkin memory is far better than Corsairs.

[Vatos_locos]

i will have to grab one 2x2 Gb kit for my sis so i will get the mushkin and compare