Reference DDR3 Micron SPD

[saaya]

sorry for the late reply guys! i kinda lost track of this thread

Tnx saaya you just save me from rma then

great

What chips does OCZ Use Sasha ?

what chips dont they use?
ask ocz which kit uses what chips

Sascha, is this same reference one you sent me ??

btw, i re-setup my blitz extreme to flash the cellshock pc3-14400 and they flashed fine...

before (left) and after (right)



This weekend, will see if this allows my cellshock to boot on DFI UT X48-T3RS

yes

What the hell Cellshock were thinking when made 900MHz JEDEC profile???

i can tell you in detail

1. hmmm still no final jedec spec for the DDR3 spds... every chip mfc programs their spds different...
2. since there is no spec, the boards ignore the SPD and calculate the timings themselves, interesting...
3. the first reviews and customer posts on forums of ddr3 show press and people complain that the spd doesnt show the kits full speed, some people feel cheated to buy 1600 memory that boots up and is recognized as 1066 memory which is a lot cheaper
4. asking around in the enthusiast community left the impression people dont really care as long as it shows the manufacturer, speed and timings.
5. some ddr3 kits that are beeing sold have impropper spd programming, but they work fine since the boards ignore the spd
6. some ddr2 boards have a fallback mechanism and ignore the spd and load their own timings if the spd doesnt work
7. seeing as there are ddr3 kits on the market with impropper spds, and there isnt a final spd spec and wont be anytime soon, its highly likely that even once a spec is out, the boards will need to implement legacy support and still boot fine with a fallback mechanism much like some ddr2 boards already do and use their own bios timings and ignore the spd.
8. ok... so lets just give people what they want, an spd that shows its ddr2 1800 or 1600 and its rated to run 876 or 766 timings.

in the end, we were wrong, at some point asus and the others started to read the spds and no longer use their own timings, probably since some memory vendors complained that their memory can run tighter timings but the board loads the same timings for every memory. this was to be expected and fine... what we didnt expect however is that asus and other mainboard makers ignored the fact that there were many ddr3 kits on the market with impropper spds, since they were programmed before there was a spd spec and in a time when spds didnt have to work fine. why they did this, and why others followed... i dont know until today...

i know that a couple of cellshock, supertalent, ocz and even corsair customers had problems with their older sticks with older spds as a result...

and kiwi, why would i recommend spdtool to flash ddr3 spds if it wouldnt work? :P

[Kasparz]

I guess none would be cheated with this
P.S. CPU-Z reads wrong XMP. All ASUS boards reads CAS8, Gigabyte reads CAS9 for XMP. ASRock won't read proper XMP memory speed at all. Intel vanilla boards won't clock anything at reasonable speeds. Even Giga X48T-DQ6 can't run 2GHz memfreq from XMP. So all that matters is that it works with ASUS excellent.

ok, glad to know at least flashing works

Sure, even if SPD is 900Mhz 1.5V mb can't force it to boot at such speed with 333fsb cpus

If 900MHz is XMP, then it will force. FSB/multi will be adjusted automatically. Actually, average people just by changing memory to XMP ready memory can overclock whole system without getting into bios. And that rocks if you're new to computers.

[saaya]

I guess none would be cheated with this
P.S. CPU-Z reads wrong XMP. All ASUS boards reads CAS8, Gigabyte reads CAS9 for XMP. ASRock won't read proper XMP memory speed at all. Intel vanilla boards won't clock anything at reasonable speeds. Even Giga X48T-DQ6 can't run 2GHz memfreq from XMP. So all that matters is that it works with ASUS excellent.

If 900MHz is XMP, then it will force. FSB/multi will be adjusted automatically. Actually, average people just by changing memory to XMP ready memory can overclock whole system without getting into bios. And that rocks if you're new to computers.

yes, IF it works, it can quite nice... but as you said, there are maaany problems with it, just like with epp.
and people who dont know what xmp is and how to oc their system, WILL oc their systems without knowing what they do, which imo is VERY bad... itll cause them and the tech support of the companies of their products a LOT of trouble

[tistou77]

Hello

I have a problem with my CellShock pc12800 D9GTR, impossible to boot with 1st at a boot (problem with the VDIMM I suppose).

is this spd solves this problem?

thank you

[tistou77]

nobody for help

[Rodriguez]

Hi Kasparz:

Have you guys at CSX changed the SPD for the x3 6Gb kits of DDR3 2000 GTR? Or do you still use the same as for the Dual Channel type.

I'm having trouble running 12Gb in Rampage 2 even at 1600, I'm waiting for another BIOS release that could possibly enhance the compatibility.

Thank you

[tistou77]

I tried to flash my CellShock 12800 D9GTR when I flash an error message (about checking), but flashing successful

but in cpu-z I have the serial number to change everything else is identical, is this normal?

thank you very much

EDIT: up please