Small D-Tek FuZion V1 vs. V2 Comparison/Review

[smee]

He's using the pro mount on both.

Looky

Yes you are correct! I used the back plate and the pro mount kit on both blocks for each test.

Today I'll be testing the quad nozzles and such.

Thanks for all the encouragement guys!!

This thread is not entirely complete yet, I just had to get up a couple of results last night so that you guys wouldn't grow so impatient and such....

Anyways, today I'm going to continue the testing, and I'll do the little review of the V2 and post it in the first post.

@Waterlogged, This testing is true testing, I just did a quick comparison like anyone here would do, I'm not an expert at this, and I'm not a big time tester like some here.
This is what the people asked me for, and thats what I gave them.
Thank you for posting.

Stay tuned folks!!!

[cegras]

Umm smee, I know your excited and all, but what you are doing is meaningless and of no benefit to anyone. You can't just take a 'snapshot' of the temps and go, this is the temp of this mount and so on. It is more complicated than that to do it somewhat right. You should first, allow each cpu to be at load for 1 hour, then, have coretemp log temps for the second hour, all the while measuring WATER temps. You can then average all cores for the hour and then subtract the average water temp for the same hour to get deltaT (difference between water temp and CPU temp). Using air temps is terribly unreliable and pretty much useless for determining CPU temps.

Right, but at least this way we know what to relatively expect going to the V2. As long as results are duplicated across both conditions, I think it's a fair comparison.

[smee]

Right, but at least this way we know what to relatively expect going to the V2. As long as results are duplicated across both conditions, I think it's a fair comparison.

YES! This is what I'm trying to do here, this was not meant to be a huge big comparison test, I just did this so that everyone can see that the V2 will beat the V1.
But until more testing done by others, we will see by how much it beats the V1.

Thanks!

[nikhsub1]

Right, but at least this way we know what to relatively expect going to the V2. As long as results are duplicated across both conditions, I think it's a fair comparison.

But it's not, that's my point. smee is now saying the v2 is 4-5C better than v1 and guess what? IMPOSSIBLE! His v1 must be BORKED if he is seeing this sort of difference. Even D-tek doesn't claim 4-5C ROFL. Block has the SAME BASE. They have the same size bores for the barbs. The real difference is v2 comes with the top/mid sealed and v1 does not, that is it. People need to open their eyes.

I may be the next to stop posting here too...

[fearo]

Or maybe you're just a grumpy man with a V1?









I'm kidding dude, relax...

[ripken204]

he speaks the truth though
it is great to see some sort of results at least

im waiting for some of our top water cooling geniuses here to make a really detailed report

[smee]

The real difference is v2 comes with the top/mid sealed and v1 does not, that is it.

I had the O-RING in the V1 when I tested it.
Both blocks were THEROUGHLY cleaned before testing, the mounts were perfectly FLAT, and there were NO air bubbles trapped between the block and chip.
My V1 is not BORKED either.

I am only 15, and this is what I'm capable of doing right now, my dad even watched me do some testing and he said I've done it all correctly.
I didn't do ANYTHING to the V1 just to make it so that the V2 would be better, I put the blocks on as if I had just gotten them from D-Tek.
The AMBIENTS were the SAME throughout each test.

I don't see WHY you guys have to keep BASHING me for this testing, this is NO different from what other people on XS do when they build rigs and get new blocks.
I did what I others did, not what the experts do because I cannot do that as I don't have the equipment nor the time.

Thank you for posting nik.

[madmaxx]

I may be the next to stop posting here too...

hopefully that does'nt happen but if it does you'll find viable options in my sig

O/P : thnx for taking the time to do a QUICK comparo

[fearo]

I had the O-RING in the V1 when I tested it.
Both blocks were THEROUGHLY cleaned before testing, the mounts were perfectly FLAT, and there were NO air bubbles trapped between the block and chip.
My V1 is not BORKED either.

I am only 15, and this is what I'm capable of doing right now, my dad even watched me do some testing and he said I've done it all correctly.
I didn't do ANYTHING to the V1 just to make it so that the V2 would be better, I put the blocks on as if I had just gotten them from D-Tek.
The AMBIENTS were the SAME throughout each test.

I don't see WHY you guys have to keep BASHING me for this testing, this is NO different from what other people on XS do when they build rigs and get new blocks.
I did what I others did, not what the experts do because I cannot do that as I don't have the equipment nor the time.

Thank you for posting nik.

Don't worry dude, almost everybody here appreciates your testing, and probably even a lot more who are just lurking around. I know there will be some more 'in depth' testing, but what you've shown us is great already. I don't care what anyone says, you put these 2 blocks in the EXACT same environment and the results show that the V2 is better than the V1. I don't care A THING about whether D-tek changed nothing about the design. 5 degrees is 5 degrees.

[Garrett]

But it's not, that's my point. smee is now saying the v2 is 4-5C better than v1 and guess what? IMPOSSIBLE! His v1 must be BORKED if he is seeing this sort of difference. Even D-tek doesn't claim 4-5C ROFL. Block has the SAME BASE. They have the same size bores for the barbs. The real difference is v2 comes with the top/mid sealed and v1 does not, that is it. People need to open their eyes.

I may be the next to stop posting here too...

I thought you might test the V2 as well... and don't you dare to stop posting here
I have a V1 myself and it beats my EK Supreme by 3c
Just curious how the V2 will do

just don't let anyone get in your head man

[klataa]

I thought you might test the V2 as well... and don't you dare to stop posting here
I have a V1 myself and it beats my EK Supreme by 3c
Just curious how the V2 will do

just don't let anyone get in your head man

Its truth! just be always honest and you will see after some time that it was worth When this block will come to my country i will be the first person who will buy it)

[I34z1k]

Nice stuff. Try get a better temp for ambient read, and download occt and run for like 30min to get a good loaded temp

[Waterlogged]

YES! This is what I'm trying to do here, this was not meant to be a huge big comparison test, I just did this so that everyone can see that the V2 will beat the V1.
But until more testing done by others, we will see by how much it beats the V1.

Thanks!

Funny, one of those "others" is telling you your testing is worthless and is hinting about leaving.
I would suggest deleting this topic and all references to the results of said testing but, too many crack heads would object.

[kinghong1970]

geesh... i think we need a GIANT for XS these days...

it seems that many folks here are going through PMS or something...

pro-smee's work... well, take note from some of these "pro's" and try to do something that's more "accurate"...

anti-smee's work... c'mon guys, give the dude some credit for effort and enthusiasm... hell, what the hell was i doing when i was 15?... in comparison to me, i applaud smee in many of his skills and efforts...

[Tw1st3d]

I agree a lot with Kinghong!

Great work Smee, not great, AWESOME!

[Vapor]

Ugh, bickering got out of hand quickly.

Closed.