I got $25 gift card and I'm on the fence on which of these games should I get.
What I'm going for in asking the same question is: Which of these two have a longer re-playability (meaning which will go old fast or one will last as long as GTR2)

I love Rallying but Dirt2 is not your typical Rally racing & the side talk trash talking is not for me. I love the eyecandy replay but the driving itself is not tight as Richard Burns or Colin McRae 2. But still fun

Drift: I like the eyecandy replay. I love that there is a community that is unselfish on sharing configs/mods/skins for making the experience better.
Driving is tighter, considering it's on asphalt vs gravel on Dirt2

I love both experiences since it gives me escapism from our mundane Midwest driving...plus my Forrester is hardly a racer.

If you have any of this game on PC please chime in your PROs & CONs on each maybe I can get a better educated decision.

Advance thanks to everyone