Noctua Launch 140mm cooler

[poparamiro]

Preliminary tests for now, the article will be very complex, anyway, i re-tested a few times because I couldn't t believe that NH-D14 would do such a great job compared to TRUE and Megahalems

[Monstru]

Well, is is surprising if you ask me. First of all I cannot explain that difference, which, from my point of view is absolutely huge. Second, this kind of design was very poorly implemented untill now, and I didn't expect too much of it at high rpm. It seems that the 6 heatpipes and the Noctua touch really added something to this beast. Anyway, this is just a sneak peak, we will know the exact situation after all tests are done and re-done.

[zalbard]

Yep, guys, looking forward to your article!

[aztec]

Originally Posted by Monstru

Well, is is surprising if you ask me. First of all I cannot explain that difference, which, from my point of view is absolutely huge. Second, this kind of design was very poorly implemented untill now, and I didn't expect too much of it at high rpm. It seems that the 6 heatpipes and the Noctua touch really added something to this beast. Anyway, this is just a sneak peak, we will know the exact situation after all tests are done and re-done.

Looks like a new King is on the way!

[dan7777]

Originally Posted by zalbard

Well, not surprising, is it? Beats Megahalems while being like twice bigger... I thought the difference would be more than 1c tbh.

+1 the megahelems for me being its size is still the king small and powerful

[Sam_oslo]

There is a big different between mounting position for this and the rest. You have to mount those others (at least Megahalems and TRUE) blowing toward the roof of the case to get the heat-piped to stay horizontal.

But if you mount this one the usual way (blowing toward the back of the case) then the heat-pipes will stay horizontal, and the liquid should flow better science it doesn't need to overcome the gravity.

[lkiller123]

Woah, the Noctua is twice as big as the TRUE. Perhaps you can combine 2 TRUEs together and see how it will compare against the Noctua

[aztec]

And the TRUE was bigger than some others that came before it, with similar whines that it was too big/too heavy. But they got over it.

[Rob94hawk]

I'd like to see this Noctua go up against this:

[Sam_oslo]

That is too heavy.

The bigger is better, as long as you can fit it in your case. The weight is very important too, but TRUE Copper has the record of 1.9 Kg.

[Rob94hawk]

Originally Posted by Sam_oslo

That is too heavy.

The bigger is better, as long as you can fit it in your case. The weight is very important too, but TRUE Copper has the record of 1.9 Kg.

What's the weight of this Noctua?

[aztec]

Originally Posted by Rob94hawk

I'd like to see this Noctua go up against this:

I'm sure we'll see plenty of shoot-outs with the Noc vs. everything else. Patience, grasshopper!

[Sam_oslo]

Originally Posted by Rob94hawk

What's the weight of this Noctua?

The Specifications says:
Weight 900g (without fan), 1070g (with one fan), or 1240g with both fans installed. This is more than Megahalems (790g without fan), but is still far less than TRUE Coper (1.9 KG without fan). It is getting really close to the limit for many MB's in a upraised case.

[wez]

Originally Posted by Rob94hawk

I'd like to see this Noctua go up against this:

http://www.thermalright.com/new_a_pa...copper/1-3.jpg

I have the noctua ordered and a lapped true cu to test against. Was hoping to have it before this weekend, but they’ve changed the delivery date so will be another week it seems..

[v0dka]

Originally Posted by Sam_oslo

There is a big different between mounting position for this and the rest. You have to mount those others (at least Megahalems and TRUE) blowing toward the roof of the case to get the heat-piped to stay horizontal.

But if you mount this one the usual way (blowing toward the back of the case) then the heat-pipes will stay horizontal, and the liquid should flow better science it doesn't need to overcome the gravity.

Huh? How big is that difference then?

I very much doubt that using the TRUE upright (maximum gravity) would give far worse temp. In fact, gas rises, and the liquid only needs to run down.

[zalbard]

Originally Posted by Sam_oslo

There is a big different between mounting position for this and the rest. You have to mount those others (at least Megahalems and TRUE) blowing toward the roof of the case to get the heat-piped to stay horizontal.

But if you mount this one the usual way (blowing toward the back of the case) then the heat-pipes will stay horizontal, and the liquid should flow better science it doesn't need to overcome the gravity.

Some people use Raven cases fyi.

[RSC]

(http://www.expreview.com/?action-viewnews-itemid-8899)

[Clunk]

http://www.clunk.org.uk/reviews/noct...er-review.html



Just posted our review. Only tested with Noctua fans, push pull on the Megahalems and TRUE, but I'll test with some more powerful fans when I get time. The other thing was that our i7 860 CPU sensor is a bit screwy at stock idle temps up to around 24C, it shows 18C in a 19C room, but once past the 24C mark it's fine.

[Computurd]

oh the endless debate on the best air cooler will rage on forever it seems. is this a viable solution for everyone, considering its size? of course not. Is the copper true realistic for everyone considering its size? of course not.
but no one is asking which is realistic for every user out there under the sun. YMMV.
the question is which is BEST.
I believe poparamiro's numbers, he is a established HS tester and has great methodology. and his numbers say this is the best out there. He did a writeup recently testing a VAST number of heatsinks. others testers are already agreeing with it as well.
maybe there needs to be size classes for the heatsinks? like heavy weights and lightweights? like boxing so people dont always have that "yeah, BUT...." to whine about.

[aztec]

Originally Posted by Computurd

oh the endless debate on the best air cooler will rage on forever it seems. is this a viable solution for everyone, considering its size? of course not. Is the copper true realistic for everyone considering its size? of course not.
but no one is asking which is realistic for every user out there under the sun. YMMV.
the question is which is BEST.
I believe poparamiro's numbers, he is a established HS tester and has great methodology. and his numbers say this is the best out there. He did a writeup recently testing a VAST number of heatsinks. others testers are already agreeing with it as well.
maybe there needs to be size classes for the heatsinks? like heavy weights and lightweights? like boxing so people dont always have that "yeah, BUT...." to whine about.

[gumballguy]

Originally Posted by Computurd

oh the endless debate on the best air cooler will rage on forever it seems. is this a viable solution for everyone, considering its size? of course not. Is the copper true realistic for everyone considering its size? of course not.
but no one is asking which is realistic for every user out there under the sun. YMMV.
the question is which is BEST.
I believe poparamiro's numbers, he is a established HS tester and has great methodology. and his numbers say this is the best out there. He did a writeup recently testing a VAST number of heatsinks. others testers are already agreeing with it as well.
maybe there needs to be size classes for the heatsinks? like heavy weights and lightweights? like boxing so people dont always have that "yeah, BUT...." to whine about.

Coz even then, people will argue against Noctua with the "colours look like a turd" argument

At least Notcua will always win the "best burgundy and salmon coloured cooler" trophy. Whatever thats worth.


That was sarcasm and yes weight is important, but its either OK or its not, it's not a relative thing. You just start with the best performers list and drop them off if theyre too heavy for your tastes

Edit: Actually its not just the weight, its also how close to the motherboard that weight is. Because its the flexure in the mobo that will damage it. So really maybe we should have bending moment rather than weight

[Computurd]

So really maybe we should have bending moment rather than weight

+1 the other day i came across a pic of a copper true in a vertical setup, i almost crapped my pants. that dude is ballsy and has very little regard for his motherboard, mounting a copper true vertically!

[jooelhoglund]

Is this noctua cooler fitting the antec p182 ?

[phantomferrari]

that thing looks awfully heavy even without the fans.! id be afraid of it snapping off and taking out my videocard