Five pumps in the Cartago´s Review






Hello and cordial welcome to new expenditure from the row „Cartago´s Review “





Introduction:




In the today's comparison several pumps step against each other, in detail are:


Phobya DC12-220

Phobya DC12-260

Phonya DC12-400 (also 2xDC-400)




Swiftech MCP350

Laing DDC-1 plus




In addition these pumps with different essays (MCP-350//Laing) and expansion tanks will prove their strengths. The essays and AGBs in detail:


Alpha-coolly Laing DDC acetal essay

Alpha-coolly Laing DDC Plexi essay

Alpha-coolly Laing DDC header tank Rev. 2

Phobya DDC Light Laing DDC Black top

Phobya Laing DDC essay - black nickel edition brass

Alpha-coolly HF 38 Cape Cyclone 250 V.2

EK Water of block input clutch reservoir Combo DCP 2,2 for EK DCP 2.2

EK Water of block input clutch reservoir for Phobya DC12-400/EK DCP 4.0






Now few words to the individual pumps:



Phobya DC12-220.

DC-220 Model is the youngest Sprössling of the very successful Phobya pumps series and also the smallest and weakest. This fine „“are so small and compactly they pumpchen into the smallest HTCP place would probably find. And there we would be with the preferential operational area these already pump, i.e. small economical and above all quiet living rooms PC. The processing was perfect, with my copy, and the scope of supply is complete with anti-vibration PAD and 2 Brackets up to the connections. Now still the technical details are missing:


Technical details:

Rated voltage: DC12V +-10%
Starting tension: DC 8V above
Capacity: 6.5W +-10%
Amperage: 0.62A +-10%
max. mechanical handling capacity: 400 L/hr +-10%
H-max.: 2.2m +-10%
Dimensions: 52 x 45 x 50mm
Life expectancy: 50000/hrs RK 25°
Volume: 17.2 railways

Scope of supply:
1 × Phobya DC12-220 12Volt pump
1 x anti-vibration PAD
2 x Brackets



Phobya DC12-260.

This pumps differs from the DC12-220 only a little, it is somewhat larger and stronger, the optical impression is just as good as with the DC12-220 and possesses the same scope of supply.

Technical details:

Color: black
Encasing material: Plastic
Dimensions housing (L x B x H): 61.7 x 59.7 x 46,7mm
Thread size: 1/4-tariff
Connection: 3Pol
Rated voltage: DC 12V
Approach tension: DC 8V
Energy consumption: 8W
Load current: 1A
max. height: 2,6m
Mechanical handling capacity: 600 L/h
Life span: 50.000h
Volume: under 21,5 railways


Scope of supply:
1x pump
Uncoupling mat
Uncoupling angle with 2x 4mm holes


Phobya DC12-400.

That is the tip of the spear this series with an achievement of 18W and a maximum hoisting depth of 4m (manufacturer data). It is quite large and very heavy. The intended operational area is clearly the HighEnd of the water cooling with several radiator and large radiators. Whether and how it against the others to become generally accepted can become we to experience later.

Technical details:

Color: black
Encasing material: Plastic
Dimensions housing (L x B x H): 75 x 66 x 54mm
Thread size: 1/4-tariff
Connection: 3Pol
Rated voltage: DC 12V
Approach tension: DC 8V
Energy consumption: 18W
Load current: 1.8A
max. height: 4m
Mechanical handling capacity: 800 L/h
Life span: 50.000h
Volume: under 25 railways

Scope of supply:
1x pump
Uncoupling mat
Uncoupling angle with 2x 4mm holes



Swiftech MCP350.

The Swiftech MCP350 very probably is and all well-known Laing DDC with a hoisting depth of 3,7m and 420L/h mechanical handling capacity. Absolute highlight with the Swiftech version:
Differently as with other suppliers, even from Laing this version completely with foam rubber PAD and retaining screws supplied those to the optimal uncoupling to directly contribute!

Technical data:

Dimensions: (BxTxH) 62x62x38mm (without connections)
Engine design: Electronically kommutierter ball engine
Rated voltage: 12 V DC DC voltage
Permissible voltage range 6 to 13.2 V
Hoisting depth with 12V: 3,7m
max. mechanical handling capacity: 420L/h
Delivery media: Water, Wasser-/Glykol-Gemische*
Max. system temperature: 60ø C
Medium-affecting parts: High-grade steel 1,4571, PPS-GF40, EPDM of O-rings,
Alumina, hard coal
Connections: 2x 10/8mm hose connector (no sleeve necessarily)

Scope of supply:
Laing DDC pump 12V DDC-1T (Swiftech MCP350) Retail
2x rubber absorber
1x MOS rubber PAD
Suitable screws, nuts & wearing parts


Laing DDC-1 plus.

This pumps is the strongest variant of the DDC series with 18W rated output and 4,7m hoisting depth with 600L/h mechanical handling capacity. I think everyone already this pump know from there save I the further description.

Technical data:

Dimensions: (BxTxH) 62x62x38mm (without connections)
Engine design: Electronically kommutierter ball engine
Rated voltage: 12 V DC DC voltage
Rated capacity: 18Watt
Permissible voltage range 6 to 13.2 V
Hoisting depth with 12V: 4,7m
max. mechanical handling capacity: 600L/h
Delivery media: Water, Wasser-/Glykol-Gemische*
Max. system temperature: 60°C
Medium-affecting parts: High-grade steel 1,4571, PPS-GF40, EPDM of O-rings, alumina, hard coal
Connections: 2x 3/8 " hose connector (for a 10mm outside diameter and 8mm inside diameter hose)

Scope of supply:
Laing DDC pump 12V DDC-1Plus




We come now to the covers and AGBs.



Alpha-coolly Laing DDC Plexi and acetal of essays.

The Plexi essay is already longer at the market and into last time by the acetal version was supplemented.
The processing of the two covers is excellent and supply complete.

Technical data:
Dimensions (LxBxH): 80 x 80 x 25mm (without connections, without pump)
Weight: 180g
Material: Acetal
Attachment: 4x M4 thread, 8x uncoupling admission
Connections: 3x G1/4 tariff thread.

Scope of supply:
1x alpha-coolly Laing DDC acetal essay
Assembly screws
Plug G 1/4 tariff


Alpha-coolly Laing DDC header tank Rev. 2

That alpha-coolly Laing DDC header tank Rev. 2 is a further module for extending and improving the Laing DDC-1T and Laing DDC-1Plus pumps. As basis here the pumps with one, already reequipped, serve alpha-coolly Laingaufsatz. Compatibly both with the 1/4-tariff version and the 3/8Zoll Highflow Alphacool Laingaufsatz!

Technical data:
Dimensions (LxBxH): 80 x 80 x 40mm (without connections, without pump)
Weight: 180g
Material: Röhm plexiglass gs
Anschlussgwindegröße: 1/4-tariff
Oil eye thread size: 1Zoll
Volume: 110ml


Scope of supply:
1x alpha-coolly Laing DDC header tank Rev. 2
1x sealing ring
1x oil eye with O-ring
4 assembly screws


Alpha-coolly HF 38 Cape Cyclone 250 V.2

This AGB is the second version of the Cyclone, the tubes diameters on 60mm was extended and a new tubing held introduction into the AGB. Turned back with the Cyclone V.2 will that landing on water Rome around 90 degrees horizontal and the tubing can at will be aligned. Alpha-coolly thereby expiration and two add the additional 1/4 tariff for e.g. on 3/8 tariff connections for and. Lighting modules ue.

Technical details.

2x G 3/8 tariff connecting thread for the use of connections with 8, 10mm or more inside diameter for High flow of systems
2x G ¼ tariff connecting thread for LED of lighting modules
Tubing with 12mm inside diameter
60 mm of pipe diameter for more volumes
90 degrees of detour in the tubing for easier filling
Eddy current effect by controllable tubing within the range of 180 degrees
Black POM cover and connecting unit, bolts with O-ring poetry
5 mm strong plexiglass pipe

Technical data:
Dimensions (HxD): 270 x 60mm
Weight: 400 gram
Material: POM, PMMA plexiglass pipe
Volume: 450 cm ³

Scope of supply:
Retailverpackung
2x fixing clips POM black.
2x G3/8 " plug
1x G1/4 " plug


Phobya DDC Light Laing DDC Black top

This essay reminds me much of the earlier OCLabs cover, it is very more easily and compact covers and at the same time one the most inexpensive Laing essays at all. Unfortunately that was not Finnish my copy so mad and pointed several small scratches and „scratches “.

Technical details:
Material: Hard plastic
Color: black
Abmssungen (without pump) (L x B x H): 76 x 62 x 28mm
Connecting thread size: 1/4 "

ROHS conform

Scope of supply:
1x Phobya DDC Light Laing DDC Black top


Phobya Laing DDC essay - Black nickel edition brass

That is, contrary to the Light version, one of the heaviest covers for the Laing. That is actually my favourite cover for the Laings. Unfortunately he sees to that with me, after estimated 50 changes corresponds out.


Technical details:
Material: Brass, nickel plates
Color: black
Dimensions (without pump) (L x B x H): 62 x 62 x 25mm
Connecting thread size: 4x 1/4 "
Uncoupling thread: M4

ROHS conform

Scope of supply:
1x Phobya Laing DDC essay - black nickel edition
2x 1/4 " cover caps, knurled, black nickel
4x assembly screw, kreutzschlitz, M4
1x foam rubber mat



EK Water of block input clutch reservoir Combo DCP 2,2 and DCP 4.0

With this AGBs EK pursued a very interesting idea, this AGBs directly to the appropriate to pump was screwed on and imagines in such a way, at least in the 2,2 version, a compact pumpen/AGB bottom plate. They are quite well finished and come with all, for the assembly necessary, will portion. The assembly is unfortunately a patience play, the Allen key provided held exactly one screw, afterwards was it no more to be used, one should absolutely a high-quality tool at home have otherwise ends the change in the endless grind.

Technical details DCP 2.2:
Material: POM (end pieces), Plexi (tube)
Thread: G 1/4-tariff

Dimensions find it here
Scope of supply:
1x EK Water of block input clutch reservoir Combo DCP 2,2 for EK DCP 2.2
1x plug

Technical details DCP 4.0:
Material: POM (end pieces), Plexi (tube)
Thread: G 1/4-tariff
They find assembly instruction here (English)

Scope of supply:
1x EK Water of block input clutch reservoir for Phobya DC12-400/EK DCP 4.0
1x plug


Test system and test run.


For this test I used the following components:

- Phobya CCU Wasserkühler S.1366
Aquatuning - the Wasserkhlung Vollsortimenter - Phobya CCU Wasserkhler S.1366 Phobya CCU Wasserkhler S.1366 EOL 10215
- Alpha-coolly HF 14 Smart Motion universal copilot by edition
Aquatuning - the Wasserkhlung Vollsortimenter - alpha-coolly HF 14 Smart Motion universal copilot by edition alpha-coolly HF 14 Smart Motion universal copilot by edition 14410
- EK Water of block EK-FC6970 acetal
Aquatuning - the Wasserkhlung Vollsortimenter - EK Water of block EK-FC6970 acetal EK Water of block EK-FC6970 acetal 12419
- Phobya Xtreme QUAD 480 radiator
Aquatuning - the Wasserkhlung Vollsortimenter - Phobya Xtreme QUAD 480 radiator Phobya Xtreme QUAD 480 radiator 35179
- Koolance flow sensor transparency inclusive electronics G1/4
Aquatuning - the Wasserkhlung Vollsortimenter - Koolance flow sensor transparency inclusive electronics G1/4 Koolance flow sensor transparency inclusive electronics G1/4 71046
- Koolance TMS-200 CONTROLLER
Aquatuning - the Wasserkhlung Vollsortimenter - Koolance TMS-200 CONTROLLER Koolance TMS-200 CONTROLLER 70037





There into this comparison test around the pumps only pure flow goes into two performance levels is measured. The Koolance control permitted, in 10 gradates, the tension of the pump between 8,11V and 12,7V to stop, and exactly I will use these values in this test. Each run was logged over 10min and the maximum and minimum values was taken up.
And here the results in a table together-chamfered:









Test evaluation.



Phobya DC12-220:

Very compactly and absolutely silent, on these values one knows the result too these pumps summarizes. The achievement is sufficient and for its planned operational area (HTCP) complete correct.
In connection with the EK DCP 2,2 it forms an inexpensive and compact Combo in nearly each housings place to find should.







Phobya DC-12 260:

This pumps is own creation of the Phobya and can not to the EK DCP AGBs be attached, from that achievement is it ago the Phobya DC12 220 not be considered clearly. The volume is equal to that of the 220, dh. In each situation practically inaudibly, only from a distance of under 30cm it is perceptible. From a closed housing it is not perceptible.





Phobya DC-12 400:

With this pumps can one the largest ones and flow braking systems operate, the achievement is outstanding. Unfortunately also the volume rises and is already clearly audible with 12V with the achievement of the pump. The kind of clay/tone is rather deep and not as whistling with the Laings and shrill. With 8V the volume this resembles itself pumps that the Phobya 260 with 12V. It should for the enterprise this pumps automatic control to be used with the achievement the pump with rising temperatures is only increased.






Laing DCC/Swiftech MCP350:

With the result too this does not pump does I quite heavily, surely is very good the achievement of the pump and exceeds those the Phobya 220 and 260 however to the Phobya 400 comes it ran. Also in the volume it strikes the Phobyas 220 and 260, is however altogether quieter than the Phobya 400 and the Laing DDC1-Plus. However the kind of clay/tone, at least for me, is very unpleasant, it is a relatively high-like whistles from not closed housings is easily audible. The Phobya BlackNickel brass cover help there little it more quietly to place which with its enormous weight to possibly do has.






Laing DDC-1 plus/Swiftech MCP355:

This pumps is, together with the Phobya DC-12 400, the strongest in this test. The achievement is enormous and without any doubt raised, however acquires this pump this achievement with very much whistling noise which also with 8V not much at volume loses. Good uncoupling and a control are obligation. However play with the pump the essay/cover very large role, could make the pump quieter with non the pluses of the brass covers, then it is alpha cool with this model that covers. Above all the acetals the kind of clay/tone of the pump could positively affect covers.
Generally speaking however is not this pump for a silent system after my measure suitably.






Result.

As one to see does not know gives it a laying eggs full milk sow into this test, all pumps has her strengths and weaknesses, one should the pump its needs and achievement requirements adapt. Direct recommendations I will not express on this place there each user other conditions to a pump set.


Thank saying:
I thank you at the companies Alphacool, Phobya, Aquatuning for the supply of the components and my friend for their patience: -)

Any write errors are my property.