Thermalright Silver Arrow VS Corsair H 100

[fab-45]

Hi,

i test new kit of corsair H100 vs silver arrow on my system :

HAF-X
asus MIVE bios 1850
2600K @ 5Ghz 1.445V and LLC 100%
gskill 2133 at 7 10 7 27 1t
artic MX 4

the test is on OCCT 15 min but i can test on other


silver arrow with 3 x TY140 temp of room is 26°c



corsair H 100 2 fan corsair push / pull with 2 noctua temp of room is 25°c



for me the corsair in push / pull = silver arrow but the noise of corsair is too much

[David-Duc]

How can you push-pull the H100 with 2 noctua ? It should be 4, right ? And the noctua fan is not good for high-density rad like H100's, gentle typhoon or any fan with rpm ~ 1400-1600 would be better. And also H100 with noctua fans shouldn't be noisier than the Silver Arrow with TY-140, the pump is dead silent.

[fab-45]

hi

i put 2 fan corsair and 2 noctua
but now i test new 2 fan scythe 110cfm and 2 fan corsair

for the noise , pump is silent but fan corsair . . . no
at the 1 level noise is very little > under silver arrow
at the 2 level is one more than silver arrow
at the 3 level . . . the sound is too up for me

[fab-45]

test with 2 scythe 110 CFM pull + 2 corsair push = 78°c max on 15 min of OCCT at 5Ghz
and test just 2 FAN corsair push = +1°c than silver arrow

[Demo]

Basically it just performs as good as the SA/D14?

[fab-45]

i think no

thermalright silver arrow have 3 fan TY 140 for take this temp

on NH D14 only 2 fan ( 1 of 120mm and 1 of 140mm)

i launch new test tomorow to see if possible to upgrade H 100 with new fan

[RealTelstar]

subscribed

[Helios1234]

Excellent findings there. I still don't understand why people would opt for the H100 over the quieter Silver Arrow is performance is what they are after.

[RealTelstar]

Simple answer. Two reasons:
1) easy access to memory and connectors around the cpu area
2) no strain on the motherboard (typical tower dissy weights 800-900g) with vertically mounted motherboards (95% of pcs i would say).