ok first let me say that i have never owned a smart phone although own an ipod touch (iphone without the camera and phone) and love it, but am very open minded about these things and went into this with said open mind.
So the wife and i decided to take the plunge and embed ourselves further in debt with a data backage and new phones.
she thought the droids looked cool because a guy at work had one (not sure which one) so we went balls deep and got the Sprint EVO 4G, and, well, they are going back today after less than 24 hours, and here's why.
(aside form the fact that she has now taken over my Ipod Touch because of all the cool apps and games that will never be on the android store)
THE BAD
- First and foremost is the android market, there are zero apps on there that neither her or I could find that were worth it, be it free or otherwise, i showed her, again, the itouch and the apple store and she was just floored at all the applications and games. The always LAME excuse that "the Android market is new" is no longer valid, and those that SITLL use that excuse are in for a very rude awakening when 1 year from now the crappy apps and games are still there, or more so not there. The market has been out long enough to have good app's and there are none, not even the most basic fun games are on the market. some light reading will easily show you that the game/app developers are NOT developing for the droid and not for lack of want, people want those apps/games but those companies are not doing it.
- Quality of app/games - ok this is huge and for the life of me i have no explanation for why this is - Games and Apps (more so the games) look like every single one, and i mean that, every one, look like they were direct ports of old Win95 DOS games. The Iphone has a few of those but i have yet to find an Android game that even looks 1/2 as good as the iphone games. why is this??? i thought the droid phones, expecially the EVO with the 1Ghz SnapDragon were a power house, well i can confirm that is not the case, they may multitask but they are NOT gaming phones, not like the iphone is turned out to be. doubt me, look at the games, then look at the iphone games. Not even the most simple games like BeJeweled are on the Android market let alone some of the wicked cool 3D or 2D scrolling shooters... again,, quality,,, and people not programming for the droid.
- Battery life,,, yup it sucks, period. everything turned off i get about 2/3 the battery life of just my Ipod.
- Mutlitasking - this will kill your gaming experience, that is IF you find a game worth having. things sit in the background and destroy the power of the platform. even using the Advanced Task Killer program games still churn out a whopping 10 frames per second or less, even some of the basic puzzle games will chug along.
- Camera - it might be 8MP but i do not think its a true 8MP, i think its probably 5mp expanded to 8. the camera is crap,,,, period. the iphone's is no better but sheesh, if you are going to put a camera like that on there use something usable. Focusing is slow, anything other than ISO 100 is horid. and Video, oh god, the video is just garbage. Again i know its a phone so i was not expecting much but i think i let the Hype go to my head. well not any longer. i know the camera and video are bad.
Not only that but they made the camera lens protrude out past the back of the camera so that if you sit the camera on its back as 99.999% of the people will, you sit it right on the camera lens cover, scratching it and beating it to hell.
The camera lens is also directly where you hold the phone so not only will you scratch it on its back, but you constantly have finger prints on the lens cover glass causing the camera to be even worse!- This is a suppliment to my multitasking comments - Most Apps do not actually shut off, they sit in the background just killing the phones performance. the Advanced Task Killer application should be included as a standard tool because you NEED it. even exiting the camera leaves it running in the background, its not live, but its a point of system resources being used for no reason what so ever.
- The build in Wifi of ryour home network (not the hotspot) is pathetic. the Ipod Touch has a MUCH better built in WiFi
- This is a sprint complaint but SprintTV is worthless, the videos are sent to you in what appears to be the lowest resolution and quality known to video codecs. massive and i mean MASSIVE pixelation, video and audio not syncing were always there. voices and video didnt exactly 100% not sync, its just that the video was such low quality and low frame rate that they didnt sync up totally, yes the video is running a low frame rate which causes choppy video.
- You've heard the Android phones are clunky? yup i can guarentee you right now any Android 2.1 phone will impress you with its choppy GUI, Menu system, and apps/games.
THE GOOD
- Network performance here at home in Cedar Rapids, IA was pretty good, supposedly 3G, so the phone says and it feels pretty fast. i ran the speedtest.net application and only got a couple of hundred kb.sec down and 700+ upload. but when you use the phone you wouldnt know the download was not that great, and with any cellular phone or carrier, speedtest NEVER show the true nature. so overall at home where i would use it most, i was happy with the network.
- GPS is supposedly real GPS with the option to use WIFI (how they GPS you for WiFi outside of your IP i have no idea), it put our location, over and over, with 100ft of my house. pretty cool!
- The screen is big and beautiful, i love it! - nuff said! - it makes the iphone look like you are holding a toy. quality wise, form what i can tell, they are equal i suppose. but i can not comment on app for app or game for game quality since nothing on the iphone i have is available for the Android,,, and i mean that nothing. and what games are available, as i stated above, look like they are DOS games. (dont believe me, try your friends droid)
- all the different gadgets and tools the EVO 4G has are pretty cool but the downside is they destroy your battery.
If you are an Android fan then i have to ask you why. i see no reason aside from what appears to be a better internet browsing experience, why you like or would want an Android based phone.
Supposedly Android 2.2 will fix the clunky issues of Android 2.1 but since no one knows when 2.2 is coming for the incredible or the EVO (officially) i am not going to take any chances on being stuck with a crappy phone with Z E R O apps or games.
the phone is cool, kudo's to HTC for making 2 killer phones (incredible and EVO) but the android is just not where its at in my opinion.
If i had never touched an Ipod or Iphone i probably would like it, nah who am i kidding i would still be pi$$ed about the droid market and its lack of ANYTHING usable. But i use my ipod touch daily and frankly, hands down there is absolutely NO comparison, none, the ipone/itouch is lightyears beyond any android based phone when it comes to apps and games.
DO NOT buy an androidphone if you like games and apps, you will hate yourself for getting one.
DO get an android, especially the EVO 4G is you want a fast internet experience on a large screen and all kinds of social networking gadgets.
other than that,,, blah! these 2 phones are going back and we are getting iphones today as it is the last day to get in with ATT and the truly unlimited $30 data plan.
Bookmarks