Printable View
Im still trying to find some thing I can use on this card to cool the core. Im pretty set on copper swiftech ram sinks for the memory. I was considering a zalman cooler for the core but Im not sure which will fit with out any modifications to it. I would aprecieate any advice for an after market cooler, even if its to wait for the release of some thing better.
the zalman vf700-cu fits. x1900 is basically the same as x1800, they're on the same pcb. the zalman would be my choice. it's quiet and effective, though I think only the attached fan won't make much flow, so I'd put an additional fan over it, to remove the heat more quickly. I'm getting the card, thinking of 3x80mm (24cm) fans on the side, the card is like 22cm.
thanks for the responce, maybe I can place a 120mm fan over the whole card cooling the zalman and memory?
according to froogle and ebay, this is the best price on that Heat sink: http://www.sureneeds.com/sureneeds/zmvf700alcu.html
I will keep it in mind but am curious to other responces on what else may fit.
that's the alcu version, u need the all copper one. maybe 5 bucks more.
If you ask people who have an x1900xt and a vf700, youll find out it doesent have enough juice to cool it.
If you run it @ stock it will overheat (85-90c). The AC Accelero X2 also cools worse than the stock cooler (but is much quieter as well, like the vf700).
The only option you have is to keep the stock cooler until the VF900 or a competitor is out.
well I will just use the stock cooler then for now. any one know what grit(s) would work well to lap the stock cooler?
Get a Sunbeam PCI Anywhere bracket...120MM fan and VF700
http://www.3dxtreme.net/other/ontap/...0/IMG_2789.jpg
http://www.3dxtreme.net/other/ontap/...0/IMG_2790.jpg
http://www.3dxtreme.net/other/ontap/...0/IMG_2792.jpg
http://www.3dxtreme.net/other/ontap/...0/IMG_2793.jpg
That'll work. Id just wait for the VF900, but then again, its not a problem for me as im on water :lol:
I got a vf-700 CU LED and its pretty much exactly the same as stock. But the heat doesnt exaust out of the case so it warms my case temp. :( But its purty. :) And the ram went down 7C. :)
Zalman fatal1ty will look sexy on Ati red PCB, and red mosfets HS.
And perform even better than VF700Cu.
just visited the Zalman website...I see that there is a Fatal1ty FS-V7 VGA cooler...is this new?...anyone have any info/reviews on this?...is this better then the VF700-CU?
If you mean this thing
I dont think its worth the extra $15 for a slightly faster fan
I have it...when other were complaining that it(vf700) wasn't enough for the x1800xt(eva2000)...the zalman cooler was enough for my x1800xt as well as the xl. I recently pulled it from the x1800xt, and i'll mount it on the x1900xt and we shall see how it goes.
the Fatal1ty cooler DOES feature a faster fan than the standard Vf700, but i'm pretty sure that the blue LED/all-copper version is just the same, without the red powdercoat.
And yes, it looks damn sexy...matches the red "mosfet" silicon heatsink.
DNOTTIS, did you remove the fan that the heatsink came with, or are you doubling them up to try to get more airflow?
when did the Fatal1ty FS-V7 come out?...is it new or has it been out for awhile now?...I bought a VF-700 CU recently...but if I had known about the FS-V7 I might have gotten that one instead...
I've had mine since early november. i think they were out before that. I picked up both the vga and the cpu cooler for the wife's rig.
the soon to be released Zalman VF900 cooler looks really nice...It is composed of a radiator equipped with copper wings crossed by two heat pipes, also out of copper...it's due out in Q2 2006
http://babelfish.altavista.com/babel...s-graphic-card
these companies are taking way too long to get anything out for the X1900 series... by the time they do, the 7900 will be out...
come on companies... make something already.
strike while the irons hot.
Couldn't have said it any better myself. They are really slacking off it seems.Quote:
Originally Posted by Kunaak
I have a Fatali-tard version coming for my XTX but the VF900 def looks ideal!
Pics of the Fatal1ty FS-V7 on X1900XT:
http://www.xtremesystems.org/forums/...1&d=1140676392
http://www.xtremesystems.org/forums/...1&d=1140676392
stock cooler, default fan speeds, stock clocks:
IDLE: 45c
LOAD: 86c
FS-V7, plugged directly into 12v 690gpu/747mem:
IDLE: 35c
LOAD: 61c
Not too bad, if you ask me.
:clap: Thanks for sharing!
I get mine in the next day or two to put on my XTX. I will let you know how it goes.
I assume you used AS5?
you bet.
I think im going to order one. this combined with swiftec ram sinks I just bought = an extra $75.00 put into my xtx. Feels like a lot of $ in a way for a few mhz.
I don't know what Zalman's problem is with holding back until possibly June to release the VF900. what is the point of that? marketing? I would have thought it would make perfect sence to release it the same time the x1900's came out. especially when its well known then vf700 is not working with the x1900's. some have said their temps went up from it??
i suspect "more than meets the eye" with bad temps reported using these coolers...pretty sure it's just the standard ones that are not enough, due to the lower-speed fan. And yes, i had one of those too, when i first got this one, and on the xl load temps increased 4c and idle 1c. Minor niggles.
One thing to note, however...mounting it right on the large die area of the x1900's can be a trifle difficult. I found the best way to mount was by holding the heatsink off the gpu while attaching one screw, lining it up, seating it, and then attaching the second screw. Simply allowing the heatsink to rest on top of the gpu while attaching the screw allows too much lateral movement that will affect how you have coated the gpu with TIM, at least in my experience.
so the FS-V7 is not meant to fix the x1900xtx's? I will have to make it work, but like you said It seems like not messing up the AS5 spread will be a challenge.Quote:
Originally Posted by cadaveca
it's the same on any card it's mounted to, imho, but even more important with the r580 because of the large die size.
I hate to say it - but this keeps my GPU at 41 Max load at max CCC overclock...(X1900XTX)
Danger Den Maze 4 GPU block. I had to go water cooling to beat the heat...
http://www.3dxtreme.net/other/ontap/...g/IMG_2899.jpg
i gotsa VF700 cu on mine.
(Disclamer: this is NOT meant to be a flame, derogatory, so PLEASE do not take offense. My sense of humor is outta wack today. Ok?)
Phooy, you guys with those VF700s are are all a buncha nubs. ;) This is how you air cool your X1900XT(X) cards. :fact:
http://myweb.cableone.net/lreedy/com...SUnveiled2.jpg
Yep first post, long time lurker however.
What about Thermalright's V1 and V1 Ultra? I own both the V1 regular and the VF700 and here is what I got as far as temps:
Stock everything: Idle 47-50C Load 85-94C
Zalman VF700 @600/1230 Idle 40C Load 67-70C
Thermalright V1 (regular) @600/1230 Idle 37C Load <60C
After playing UT2004 for about 40 minutes the V1 did not even break 60C. Quite amazing. (By the way I used two fans on the V1 so that probably helped.)
Edit: I read about that mod on Anandtech Bull Dog. I really like what you did with that.
Why thank you. :)
Awesome mod!
What you used to bend the heatpipes Bull Dog ?
I had the fan mounted on the brackets(stock position) and I used my two hands. I just took it real slow and I didn't see any signs of kinking until the very end so it wasn't a problem.
So the heatpipes got some quality... Nice.
Thanks for posting this here.
Im kinda torn on what i want for this too, the accelero looks great just for the noise levels but that v1 ultra would be my perferred choice if it perfroms decently
I have a new project log done for anyone thats interested.
http://myweb.cableone.net/lreedy/com...X19V1Upt2.html
Automatic fan control based on temperature, somthing completely unrelated to video cards, and a custom PWM IC heatsink.
http://myweb.cableone.net/lreedy/com...1-compare2.jpg
recently purchased the Zalman Fatal1ty FS-V7 cooler for my X1900XT card...much better then the stock cooler in looks and performance...the red LED adds a nice contrast to the Blue LED case fans..here are some pics...
http://img461.imageshack.us/img461/227/197sb.th.jpg http://img453.imageshack.us/img453/6819/160hw.th.jpg
http://img461.imageshack.us/img461/1139/93ej.th.jpg http://img453.imageshack.us/img453/6459/305xg.th.jpg
so what temps you getting now compared to the stock cooler Titus?
average temps with Zalman FS-V7 (performance setting)-- idle= 42 load= 55Quote:
Originally Posted by cantankerous
never used the stock ATI cooler so not sure what those temps are...but according to reviews etc stock idle= 57 and load= 77
Awesome stuff bull dog. I'll keep an eye out for you, because I'm sure I'll be seeing more cool stuff from you in the future:)
if there's any truth in this comparison then the thermalright cooler would be best.
http://www.legionhardware.com/document.php?id=525
I hear that the stock cooler beats a vf-700 in gpu cooling. :-\ I know it does with my x1900xtx.. those stock coolers pwn.
I think they are loud and not very good at cooling imhoQuote:
Originally Posted by POGE
Here's a pic of my extra special "Air Jordan" mod.
Isn't that thing too small for a R580?Quote:
Originally Posted by HousERaT
too small? no aftermark retail cooler can match this cpu heatsink in performance.Quote:
Originally Posted by Pisu87
houserat, what are your temps and at what cfm/dba (fan)?
and voltage/oc on the card too?
This is using the little fan on the left which is a little faster than the stock fan. The specs for the fan is 5300RPM 23.39 cfm with 38.65 dBa (I can't hear it over the case fans). The card I'm using is the 1900XT @ 729/810 with voltages of 1.500 - 2.102 - 2.086 - 1.501. With those votages the card is idling right now at 38° after I've run the bench. Obviously with the bigger fan the temps are even better but it's a beast.Quote:
Originally Posted by chinkgai
Nice mod HousERaT. Afraid I've got your temps beat but none-the-less, very nice.
with the noisy fan the temps are about 2-4° better. What are your temps with equal volts/clocks?Quote:
Originally Posted by Bull Dog
Quote:
Originally Posted by Bull Dog
cheap cpu heatsink ghetto strapped on there vs 45 dollar heatsink :stick:
ghettomod FTW!!
I just want to know if the thermalright can keep up with my cpu heatsink at higher voltages?
So, guys, now that Thermalright has released a X1900-compatible V1 Ultra, how do you think it will do performance-wise? I know running it passive isn't feasible, but how high-powered of a fan would I need? I'm just trying to decide between the VF900 and V1.
Seems to be ok with a mild overclock. I haven't seen one maxed out yet but it's a nice retail alternative.Quote:
Originally Posted by Istasi