--Conroe max temp debate--
I have read many conflicting results on temp monitoring. My general understanding was that to be 100% safe keep ur cpu under 55c and 1.5v (for air). But, using which type of temp monitoring? Here is my example.
I am assuming both of my readings are correct here because it would make sense for speedfan to read lower then a direct core reading.
Speedfan:
Mobo - idle39c/load41c
Cpu - idle25c/load46c
Hdd - 22c
For comparison the mobo and cpu temps are reported the same in the bios (1305)
Coretemp:
Cpu - idle40c/load58c (both cores are kept around the same temps cause of Orthos priming, so I made it one reading).
So whats the deal here? Assuming they are both correct, which one should be under 55c? And if its speedfan, what should be my max coretemp because the Tcoremax is rated at 85c.
P.S. I have a stacker with a 1 120mm back exaust (having it intake make help my si-120 though...), 1 120mm front instake, 1 80mm top exaust, 1 makeshift 120mm blowing down on my ram/chipset, and 1 120mm mounted on my si-120.
Why would you want to debate about temps?
Why debate with absolute strangers... when the Specificationsare available for all to read.
Thats one of the great things about Intel. Their documentation.
None of this brokeee ingleesh from competitors.
Look go to the Intel web site. Look up processors.... Core 2 duo
Then look up documentation.
What you want is a pdf sorta like E66xx series family DATASHEETS.
There one can find EXACTLY how it is supposed to work.
Granted Chapter 5 is a tough read... It is written for engineers.
But if one was half way decent in High School, they should be able to
muddle through and get the drift.
One can ask a hundred people online and get a hundred different opinions.
What you need to do is go to the source.
Guys PLEASE Read the Manual
From Intel:
Intel core 2 extreme Processor x6800 and Intel core 2 duo desktop processor E6600 sequence
First of all Throttelling does not occur at just one temperature, it is a function of power being consumed by the processor at that instant.
Y = mX + b (Y = Throttle temp, x = watts currently being consumed)
(Thank you Mr Yaches, HS math teacher}
************************************************
For the Core 2 Exteme X6800 : Y = .23x + 43.2C
X or the Power, ranges from 0 to 75 watts
Thus throttling for this processor can occur anywhere from 43.2C to 60.4C
I don't know how to tell exactly how many watts the processor is consuming at an instant. But this much I know: IF THE E6800 IS AT OR BEYOND 60.4C IT IS THROTTLING, AND YOU ARE LOSING PERFORMANCE.
************************************************** *******
For the Core 2 Duos with 4MB L2 cache Y = .26x + 43.2C
X or the Power, ranges from 0 to 65 watts
Thus throttling for this processor can occur anywhere from 43.2C to 60.1C
I don't know how to tell exactly how many watts the processor is consuming at an instant. But this much I know: IF THE E6700 OR E6600 IS AT OR BEYOND 60.1C, IT IS THROTTLEING AND YOU ARE LOSING PERFORMANCE.
************************************************** *******
For the Core 2 Duos with 2MB L2 cache Y = .28x + 43.2
X or the Power, ranges from 0 to 65 watts
Thus throttling for this processor can occur anywhere from 43.2C to 61.4C
I don't know how to tell exactly how many watts the processor is consuming at an instant. But this much I know: If the E6300 OR E6400 is at or beyond 61.4C IT IS THROTTLING AND YOU ARE LOSING PERFORMANCE.
================================================== =====
NOW WAIT JUST ONE DANG SECOND !!!
YOU MEAN TO TELL ME MY CHIP CAN BE THROTTLED AT EVEN 50c ????
YES !
I know its not intuitive... but bear with me for one more second...
Consider two identical chips, one is at 59C currently consumming 65 watts
the other is at 50C consumming only 10 watts... Which one is in trouble?
Actually it is the cooler second chip that is in trouble, and the one that will be throttled.
The first chip is consuming almost max power and working its tail off, but it is staying within the defined limits of throttling. He is ok.
Its the second chip, the cooler one, is beyond his recommended temps, given the power he is consuming.
Analogy: Two people:
One is currently exercising (running a mile) and has a current heart rate of 90
the second is sitting and has a heart rate of 85
Who is more in trouble?
================================================== ======
Ok now lets define throttling:
Thermal Monitor : turns the clocks on and off rapidly
Will occur at Throttle point defined above,
but definitely by (60.1 to 61C depends of Processor type)
Thermal Monitor 2 : Lowers the voltage to the processor,
and reduces the multiplier
Will be applied after Thermal Monitor if Thermal Monitor
doesn't bring temps back below current throttle point.
Thermal Trip - the drastic action of shutting off the power to the processor
after it reaches about 25C higher than the throttle point.
================================================== =======
I don't know of any up to date software that actually shows Throttling for the New C2D and C2 extreme processors.
Some people say they monitor it in TAT, but I think they are misinterpretting the Software induced throttling feature of that package. The processor not only throttles itself, but allows the software to command it to.
If I am wrong about the TAT, someone please correct me,
I would like to see a screen shot...if you could.
{I don't like to heat my 600$ investment up just to prove this point. :)
================================================== ====
Hope I'm correct on all the above...
One always loses something in simplification...
Its not simple...
But remember you do have the manual...
{written for a higher level than me... but I tried...
The DTS is monitoring the same sensor that activates TCC
Quote:
Originally Posted by Fred_Pohl
This really is getting out of hand. Yes, the DTS are more accurate than the thermal diode but the temps they report have nothing to do with the max Tcase temp of 60C.
Fred some of what you say is true, but you are mistaken about a number of points. I can only address them one by one. I will address the others as I have more time.
See Intel Core 2 Duo Destop Processor Sequence Thermal and Mechanical Desing Guidelines.
Specifically Paragraph 1 Section 4.2.10
"The DTS is monitoring the same sensor that activates TCC."
So you see it is the digital thermal sensor (the one reported by core temp)
that one should be concerned with.
e6300 IHS WAS nowhere near flat!!!
I modified my e6300's IHS, by protecting it with the shipping cover, then rubbing it flat on very, very fine grade wet & dry sandpaper.
This put the IHS's sides on the same level as the middle and it had an unexpected benefit... it exposed a nice little copper spot directly above the core, right in the middle of the IHS...
The reason I did this is because, when I place a straight edge over IHS, it was dished in middle. it was the best part of 1mm higher on the outsides!!! Meaning no contact at the core (middle)!!
Then I lapped it with good quality car polish...
Voila!!!, 10oC cooler than previous!!! :D