So what do you say, better to get a 120.4 or a 140.3, which one would perform better?
Printable View
So what do you say, better to get a 120.4 or a 140.3, which one would perform better?
me too :confused:Quote:
Originally Posted by aka_GK
I would also like to know that.Quote:
Originally Posted by p2501
so ... is thermochill is making a comeback?
I would guess the 120 radiator would cool better because of more surface area over the 140.
120.4: 120mm*480mm=57600mm^2Quote:
Originally Posted by Nanometer
140.3: 140mm*420mm=58800mm^2
(ignoring fan spacing etc)
Looks about equal to me.
How about hydro restriction, is there big difference between 120.3, 120.4 and 140.3?
Will be DDC1T 10w enough with Heatkiller LT and NB block?
lmao yea , i calculated it wrong lol, thanks for the correctionQuote:
Originally Posted by alacheesu
OK. This radiator is big.. but what fans it can take? I mean what 140mm fans do you guys know ?
I know these, wonder which would be the best:
* Xigmatek XLF-F1453 LED 1000 RPM 63.6 CFM 16 dBA
* Sharkoon 1500rpm 33db(A) 140.7m³/h
* Sharkoon 1200rpm 27db(A) 109.6m³/h
* Sharkoon 900rpm 22db(A) 82.8m³/h
* Yate Loon D14SL-12 1000 RPM 46.0 CFM 25 dB(A)
* Yate Loon LED version (which is same as above)
I just got reply from Noctua about their 140mm fan NF-P14 - it will be available Q4-09/Q1-2010..
However look on photo.. it will be round fan, with 120mm screw holes... so don't think it would be ok for 140mm radiators....:(
http://www.dvhardware.net/news/noctu...computex09.jpg
Yeah, those Noctua fans will have the same problem as the Scythe 140mm fans = 120mm hole spacing so it won't work on 140mm rads. The only 1400m rad I can think of it would work on is the TFC Monsta because its shroud has holes for both 140mm and 120mm fans.
I hate Noctua and Scythe for their good fans with 120mm mounting holes :mad:
Did anyone test this radiator? Anyone bought it?
gilgameshreviews.com tested it, I will be getting one in the next 2 weeks supposedly
Well, I wrote about them, they tested prototype one, shorter version.Quote:
Originally Posted by SNiiPE_DoGG
I'm just wondering how much better it is compared to regular 3x120.
Would it be similar to 4x120?
140.3 is better than 4 x 120 ---> more surface area on the 140.3 and the fan blade area to motor hub area ratio on 140mm fans is greater by a large amount .
120.3 = 43,200 mm^2
120.4 = 57,600 mm^2
140.3 = 58,800 mm^2
120mm fans is 6.09:1 fan blade area to motor hub area ratio
140mm fans is 8.64:1 fan blade area to motor hub area ratio
then by calculation of fan blade area ((Pi*fanradius^2)-(pi*hubradius^2))*#fans) we can say utilized area.
120.3 = 29,127 mm^2
120.4 = 38,837 mm^2
140.3 = 41,373 mm^2
therefore PA140.3 is ~6% better than PA120.4 @ equal fan speed and design on each (120mm yate loon and 140mm yate loon for instance)
I am quite sure one of the part manufacturers on this board could whip up a quick adapter that would allow those Noctua fans to fit 140mm fan screw spacing... at the same time, their bracket could seal off the remaining area the fan doesn't cover, so all of the fan's air is directed into the radiator. This would also be nice in a shroud format.
I actually thought about it few days ago, that would be a great idea, using your favourite 120mm fans and having that bracket as shroud!..Quote:
Originally Posted by 3Z3VH
http://www.frozencpu.com/products/90...62&id=rpCAhnZf
http://www.frozencpu.com/images/prod...ain/duc-49.jpg
here we go, PA 140.3 and LL PC-P80
http://img19.imageshack.us/img19/8803/img4682q.th.jpg
this thing is bigger than I've expected :shakes:
Nice... still looks huge in that case.
Is there a proper review of that radiator?
No proper review yet, only the one at gilgamesh but that isn't a review at all
Well yes but aint fans alot more optimized in the 120mm section? And therefore making the 120.4 about the same in performance?Quote:
Originally Posted by SNiiPE_DoGG
look at my utilized area calculations.Quote:
Originally Posted by Mech0z
SNiiPE_DoGG is right, he nailed it spot on:)
It is a bit better than 120.4 - but it would be easier to install 130 rad than longer 120.4...
Agree. It is easier to fit wide rad, rather than long.Quote:
Originally Posted by phinix_mike
I dunno how I've calculated height but I hoped that I will have enough room for one hdd cage with 140.3 in P80 :D now I see that I have place only for dvd or fan controller and I am glad - with 120.4 I wouldn't have even this :)