What? Cathar was partially responsible for the 1/2" madness? You Darth Vader!!!!!!!!!
;)
Printable View
What? Cathar was partially responsible for the 1/2" madness? You Darth Vader!!!!!!!!!
;)
Nice to see a technical review of the tubing/flow issue. I kind of figured what you documented was happening turning my D5 to 1 and seeing no temp change. Great work! Good to dispell the escalating group-think on flow requirements.
hmmmmmmm......
Sir,Quote:
Originally Posted by HiJon89
With all due respect, I will disagree and argue with whoever and whomever I see fit, including the Queen of England and the Emperor of Japan.
As far as I am concerned, everyone puts on their pants a leg at a time, and the last time I checked, we all sat on the potty at 3 or 4 years old, whether or not the potty was made of plastic or gold. The resulting output remains the same, no matter which continent we are on.
I will not subscribe to stuff spouted out as widely as my leaky garden hose connection to the faucet. This is the same guy, not too long ago, that swayed public opinion from 3/8 to 1/2 and then back down to 7/16, and now its back to 3/8 and he's even suggesting 5/16.
As far as I am concerned, he's just another product innovator, of which there are a baker's dozen. He's made his mark via a product, where the product's intellectual property was sold/transferred. He couldn't even yield commercial success out of the product. Reminds me of Xerox, which invented just about everything that one can mention, but could not generate any commercial success out of any of its inventions. Visions of the phrase "washed up" come to mind.
Then get used to being the laughing stock of the forum :rolleyes:Quote:
Originally Posted by IanY
Like I said, all are free to laugh all the time :)Quote:
Originally Posted by HiJon89
Ouch!Quote:
Originally Posted by Cathar
Ian I thought you wanted to stay off trouble? Nice bomb drop :rolleyes:
I agree with you that even the watercooling "gods" can be questioned, and in fact I think it should happen more often. But you got no real argument other than a tubing misunderstanding!
If everyone agreed with you then there would be no innovation and nothing to build upon.Quote:
Originally Posted by HiJon89
If I have evidence that something anyone said is wrong I sure as hell will argue about it with them no matter who they are.
Im not saying I agree with Iany on this one but I think this statement is completely false and should not be followed by anyone.
I make exceptions when I smell the foul stench in the air.Quote:
Originally Posted by migueld
A guy that posts an infantile image from a website called plasticnipple.com wants to talk to me about growing up?Quote:
Originally Posted by [XC] riptide
I was around before you were an itch in your ... never mind...
What evidence could you have that such people wouldn't already know about? Any testing data you look at, they compiled. Any phase change guide you follow, they wrote. Any idea you think of, they thought of it first. By all means, feel free to argue with whoever you want, but let IanY's experiences with Cathar be a lesson to you. Mess with a legend, and you get put in your place ;)Quote:
Originally Posted by bartsimsonii
IanY. I never told you to grow up in this thread anyway. Maybe you should reread... it was Cathar.Quote:
Originally Posted by IanY
I can see Ian's point to a degree (playing devil's advocate here) as he has not been around that long and is enamored with Swiftech. He has every right to say whoa! WTF? However, Stew has presented pretty credible DATA to back up what he is saying, there is no blind faith here Ian - there is data to prove what he says. Arguing against something which is proven as fact is what is know as being an idiot. There is no theory to argue against here.
Ian you love to claim that you go 'against' the masses yet, the masses here are for big bore tubing. The impact of small tubing is far less detrimental than one would expect, sure there are small differences but not enough to lose sleep over.
Where is the 'stench' you speak of? I hope you like the role of class clown because you have more than earned it.
I love the role of class clown. Enjoying every minute of it.Quote:
Originally Posted by nikhsub1
Are the masses here for big bore tubing? Are they? What is that 7/16" ID nonsense that been spouted on here for eons ? I use 1/2" ID religiously and I am proud of it.
I haven't been around as long? Around in XS. Yeah.
That "scientific data" in the form of more charts were also around in ProCooling when he advocated going from 3/8 to 1/2. Then from 1/2 to 7/16. Now from 7/16 to 3/8.
I guess the laws of physics change every year.
And to address your point, I question Gabe as well. You saw me give him a bit of a hard time about the Stealth. However, at least Gabe had the gumption to call a spade a spade, and when the time for the Storm was up, Gabe also told it, but you guys chose to make fun of the Apogee design instead of looking into it.
It took a 13 year old boy to scream "WTF.. Stop putting vinegar into your radiators." Even then, he got ridiculed, and nobody ever gave him any credit.
I guess low flow and low pressure is now "in"... so you guys can stop buying the Petra tops!
Damn... I'm getting very close to inserting into the sig.
John Guest Pushfits... there are a few versions, but of the ones we have here... (no 12mm in stock at the mo as far as I can tell/find)Quote:
Edit: You might have a look upon the Jonh Guest parts , altough I don't know if they have the same characteristics as the Legris parts.
G1/4" > 8mm OD tubing PM010802E = 6.5mm bore thru the fitting
G3/8" > 8mm OD tubing PM010813E = 6.5mm bore (2 diff versions of this fitting)
G3/8" > 8mm OD tubing PM010803E = 7mm bore (2 diff versions of this fitting)
G3/8" > 10mm OD tubing PM011013E = 10mm bore (but with a narrowing to 7mm at the base of the collar then back up to 10mm thru the threads)
Meh - argue with me on anything u like, as long as you have some evidence to support your side of the argument. If someone says "Father Christmas exists" I say "prove it". It's down to the person making the claims to provide their unbias proof (pref via double-blind testing) to back it up. No proof = worthless claim.Quote:
or Marci for that matter)
Ok boys and girls, back on topic here. So if were going to make a recommendation to a NOOB what would be the verdict? Lets say were using the DDC-2, a D-Tek Fuzion and a MCW60. What tubing, tubing size, barbs, pushfits etc. are we using here?
Just thought I'd try to nail it down to help some peps out.
Well based on the results of Cathars tests, it barely makes difference. choose whatever tube size you want. You won't see a few degrees between smaller sized tubing. And I can back it up.
Since I'm in Europe - I've been using 10/8 tubes for years, when I 'upgraded' to 1/2" it barely made any difference in temperature. within a degree C probably.
and the difference between the two is 1.6mm, they are both big bore tubing.Quote:
Originally Posted by IanY
To my mind Cathar has posted up data to rid any myths of big being better with respects to tubing so the masses are free to choose what they want and so with sound judgement. I think this is just a trolling attempt.
Agree whole heartedly.Quote:
Originally Posted by Terryb47
To me, that graph just says - choose what ever tubing you want, as it hardly makes a difference.
Taking into consideration, people choose tubing on bend radius, clarity, value for money, non stain properties.
I think there is still value in 7/16" tubing over 1/2" barbs for the budget-minded general watercooler. You can get 7/16" cheaper than borch in Russia and the fit over the 1/2" barbs is close to perfect.
Where cost is not a concern, as Mekrel says, get the tubing that has the exact properties for your application and rest easy knowing you haven't compromised on performance.
I think that it comes down to individual preference- Seeing the minor difference in just a CPU loop would tell us that it makes little difference what diameter we use. So if I was trying to watercool in a Shuttle case, I would use 7/16" ID 5/8" OD with some Coolsleeves to make those super-tight bends. At the same time, if I was watercooling in a Mozart case, I might go for 1/2" because there is no need for a smaller diameter tube and I can afford to lose space in such a big case.
I still would like to see a test done with at least another block. I vote Fuzion + a GPU block. Why? Because I think the differences might become more apparent as we introduce more restriction into the blocks.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Marci
http://imagescommerce.bcentral.com/m...laus%20wig.jpg
Sorry marci, i just had to do it :rofl: :rofl: :up:
@ Iany, i say we do what we do best. Just do your own tests and see if it does indeed not make a big difference.
3/8 Barbs and 3/8 tubing is like buying a cup of coffee for you and me. :P