a lot of us got the Bone Trail based solely on the solid reputation of its predecessor, the Intel Bad Axe II. it was respected as one of the most solid and stable overclockers from its generation.
i think the Bone Trail is no different - it just got off to a shaky start and could still use another BIOS revision. it isn't quite as refined as the other, more expensive boards, and it doesn't have as many extras. but once i figured out how to stroke mine the right way, it has proven to be a powerful board. i got my FSB up to 467 last night, and my CPU was what held me back from going higher. the Bone Trail didn't even break a sweat.
is the BT right for you? that depends. it requires DDR3 memory, which is still very expensive. DDR3 won't affect your gaming performance or help you surf the web faster, but i can compile video with this machine like you wouldn't believe. memory-intensive programs just scream now. X38 is an expensive chipset and should only be considered by people who want the option to CrossFire their video cards imo. other than that, the board has stellar onboard audio and some very nice home theater tools, like its IR receiver built in. the IO panel has eight USB ports and two E-SATA ports, which are very convenient if you need that stuff.
i've basically only had mine for a month, but it appears to be rock solid and stable now that i've got it set up right. i'm confident that i can push my computer as hard as i want all day without having to worry about anything overheating or crashing on me. my CrossFire performance is awesome and i'm ready for the next generation video cards when they come out. i hope i can afford two R700's when they're released. i think i have about the 30th fastest dual core 3DMark06 score in the world right now.