Personally? I think it's a dumb buy. $19 more and you get a 2800+ with 512k cache... Which I'd wager gives slightly more performance boost than 512k-1m cache did... and people paid easily $100 at times for that jump. I wouldn't be surprised if we see this processor goes down to ~$100 over the next month, month and a half as AMD tries to push the phase out of Socket A. Unless there is at least $30 difference I would never take this over a Newcastle (Unless this overclocks better).