Seasonic 750w Explodes

Printable View

Show 100 post(s) from this thread on one page

12-21-2008, 07:17 PM
OS-Wiz

Quote:

Originally Posted by Oklahoma Wolf

[nitpick]
That would be me who wrote the review... jonnyGURU's retired ;)
[/nitpick]

In an astonishing coincidence, that seems to be an SG-850 in my sig powering my main rig. I wonder how that could have happened :D

Ah ha, the wolf strikes :D Outstanding choice in a PSU :up:
12-22-2008, 08:52 AM
Russ_64

If it was new then maybe it took a hard knock in transit. I had an Antec Truepower 550 blow up on me after a house move ...... replacement Seasonic S12 600 is still going strong.
12-22-2008, 09:28 AM
moiraesfate

I didn't know it was possible for them to explode like that. Fry, yes, but explode? Lucky you weren't hurt.

Don't write off Seasonic for one psu. Thats probably one in a million thing.
12-22-2008, 12:52 PM
OS-Wiz

Quote:

Originally Posted by moiraesfate

I didn't know it was possible for them to explode like that. Fry, yes, but explode? Lucky you weren't hurt.

Don't write off Seasonic for one psu. Thats probably one in a million thing.

Read this, all three of us that ordered one had it blow up! :down:

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Produc...82E16817151068
12-22-2008, 02:05 PM
Oklahoma Wolf

Trusting Newegg reviews for reliability info is like trusting Enron for stock tips though. Anyone with a keyboard can write those things.
12-22-2008, 04:05 PM
OS-Wiz

Quote:

Originally Posted by Oklahoma Wolf

Trusting Newegg reviews for reliability info is like trusting Enron for stock tips though. Anyone with a keyboard can write those things.

Agreed, but 3 outta 3 says something. And I agree that Seasonic makes good PSUs, I've had one running in the PC I built for my son for a couple years now. But I think their first DC-to-DC (M12D) attempt has, at best, been a shakey start.
12-22-2008, 04:13 PM
Oklahoma Wolf

Not really... it just says that three people had their units die and decided to go make their opinions known. There could be 300 or 1000 positive experiences to those three negatives you didn't hear about ;)

When everything's working right, most people usually don't think twice about it. Something goes wrong, suddenly they're all over the message boards telling others about it. In general, Seasonic is well above average in reliability. The RMA replacement is very, very unlikely to have a problem.

Ah, the M12D. That there is an interesting case. Got a review on it scheduled for the 26th at jonnyGURU.com. Lots of interesting stuff to talk about on that one.
12-22-2008, 08:46 PM
Sparky

Quote:

Originally Posted by vengance_01

Don't buy any Corsair HX units. Seasonic makes good stuff. Just RMA it and be done. Things happen.

Why not? :shrug: jonnyguru gave them good reviews and I have one too and am very pleased with it.
12-22-2008, 08:50 PM
shanems3

Quote:

Originally Posted by elpibe10

I've experienced something similar with another brand of psu and the culprit was a spider that managed to crawl inside and electrocuted itself (and took the psu and mobo with it in the process). :(

how did you find out it was a spider, if it blew, wouldnt it zap the critter??
12-22-2008, 08:54 PM
Sparky

Quote:

Originally Posted by shanems3

how did you find out it was a spider, if it blew, wouldnt it zap the critter??

SPIDER GUTS! :p:
12-23-2008, 03:21 AM
largon

Where's jonnyguru's (as in the site) review of Seasonic M12D?
Was their sample DOA, perhaps?
:p:
12-23-2008, 05:42 AM
Oklahoma Wolf

It's coming on Friday.
12-23-2008, 05:46 AM
saki_bomber

Quote:

Originally Posted by SparkyJJO

Why not? :shrug: jonnyguru gave them good reviews and I have one too and am very pleased with it.

well i have a corsair HX1000 and i already have a thread about this - im getting a burning smell running the components in my sig. shouldnt be anywhere close to taxing my psu - i have submitted an RMA a week ago and have yet to hear back from them.

i might not buy another corsair either, depending on the outcome of this one. the no response is not helping any. in the meantime im without a pc unless i just bite the bullet and get another psu - the antec 850 that everyone is talking about looks nice but they have a bad rep and i dont know if i want to take the chance:shrug:
12-23-2008, 06:10 AM
Oklahoma Wolf

You have noticed what time of year it is, haven't you? A lot of companies are running on reduced hours this week, and/or are busier around the holidays.

As for the Antec, if I had any doubts about it, it wouldn't be in my main rig right now. It's the best unit I've ever reviewed. When/if I find something better, that one will go into my main rig. I must admit though - those big Ikoniks came real close.
12-23-2008, 06:18 AM
saki_bomber

Quote:

Originally Posted by Oklahoma Wolf

You have noticed what time of year it is, haven't you? A lot of companies are running on reduced hours this week, and/or are busier around the holidays.

As for the Antec, if I had any doubts about it, it wouldn't be in my main rig right now. It's the best unit I've ever reviewed. When/if I find something better, that one will go into my main rig. I must admit though - those big Ikoniks came real close.

its tempting to get the antec, i remember you from anandtech if i remember correctly.

whats the unit called again? do you have a link to the review?
do you think it'll handle a CF setup?

the major name brands i've had so far are silverstone 750, corsair hx1000, pc power and cooling silencer 750 - the only one not to give me trouble so far is the pc power and cooling. the silverstone is long gone (popped from a previous CF setup) and the corsair is flaking out with burning wire smell with the current setup. i swear i have bad luck with psu's and i DONT EVEN OVERCLOCK.
i might check out this antec thats getting these praises
12-23-2008, 06:59 AM
Oklahoma Wolf

Here you go: http://www.jonnyguru.com/modules.php...Story&reid=101

Yes, it will do Crossfire. With 4870x2 cards if you want it to.

Actually, I don't post on Anandtech. This forum, OCForums, and Extreme Overclocking are the only ones I visit on a regular basis. Other than jonnyGURU forums of course ;)
12-23-2008, 07:42 AM
saki_bomber

Quote:

Originally Posted by Oklahoma Wolf

Here you go: http://www.jonnyguru.com/modules.php...Story&reid=101

Yes, it will do Crossfire. With 4870x2 cards if you want it to.

Actually, I don't post on Anandtech. This forum, OCForums, and Extreme Overclocking are the only ones I visit on a regular basis. Other than jonnyGURU forums of course ;)

hmm thought it was anandtech but it was literally a year or 2 ago - maybe it was [H]ardOCP forums? maybe its that one im thinking about. oh well, doesnt matter.

thanks for the link, i'll check it out. so it'll do 4870x2 CF? impressive, does it push the psu to the upper limits though?
12-23-2008, 07:51 AM
Oklahoma Wolf

It comes close, but this is one PSU that shouldn't complain about that much load. It's built to go the distance.

I forgot Hardforums - I post there too once in a while.
12-23-2008, 08:25 AM
OS-Wiz

Quote:

Originally Posted by Oklahoma Wolf

It's coming on Friday.

So, did it blow up :rofl:
12-23-2008, 08:28 AM
Oklahoma Wolf

You'll find out on Friday :p:
12-23-2008, 08:39 AM
saki_bomber

Quote:

Originally Posted by Oklahoma Wolf

It comes close, but this is one PSU that shouldn't complain about that much load. It's built to go the distance.

I forgot Hardforums - I post there too once in a while.

hmmm maybe i'll pick one up and see what happens while i wait for the corsair rep to get back to me. i really need one, and i have a feeling it might take a while. :(
12-23-2008, 08:48 AM
Mav451

Quote:

Originally Posted by saki_bomber

hmmm maybe i'll pick one up and see what happens while i wait for the corsair rep to get back to me. i really need one, and i have a feeling it might take a while. :(

I PMed Red Beard on [H] to get an advanced RMA for my 620HX, when I was diagnosing the squeal. If you have an acct there, I'd PM him to get this expedited. Otherwise, I suppose you could go the long way too...
12-23-2008, 09:19 AM
saki_bomber

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mav451

I PMed Red Beard on [H] to get an advanced RMA for my 620HX, when I was diagnosing the squeal. If you have an acct there, I'd PM him to get this expedited. Otherwise, I suppose you could go the long way too...

i pm'd him also, and he said to contact him in a few days if i didnt hear anything back (which i havent) so i pm'd him again last night to let him know.
i guess i'll hear something back soon, he seems reliable.
12-23-2008, 09:25 AM
Tonucci

Quote:

Originally Posted by OS-Wiz

I just had a SeaSonic M12D SS-750 750W PSU blow up not more than two feet from my head :eek: Big explosion and some fireworks. Scared the hell outta me. I'd never had a PSU cap blow on me and I musta jumped a foot straight up :ROTF: It lived for about 15 secs.
Needless to say I'll not be ordering another SeaSonic :down:
I'd done some research and the PSU was getting some good reviews; maybe I just got a bad one. Regardless, I ordered an Antec Signature 850W to replace it.
Anyway, newegg was very good about it; they are going to refund shipping costs here and back and no restocking fee! Gotta luv that newegg customer service.

Seasonic make awesome proven PSU's.... **** happens, bad luck :(

But if I were you I would file an law suit, for the health risk you went through. You will probably win good cash (plus everything Uve spent with lawyers etc) if it really exploded like that :yepp:

The mere possibility of you being near it when it blew, damaging/killing yourself, the mere possibility of it burning your house down and the "immaterial" issues like emotional stress, scared, not trusting PCSU's anymore etc... Also the days you may have gone without an working PC, damaging your studies/work or messing with your daily routine.

Im an lawyer.... so i can say that all of these are possibilities for u to earn an nice sum of money :)
12-23-2008, 02:04 PM
Luphy

Quote:

Originally Posted by OS-Wiz

Read this, all three of us that ordered one had it blow up! :down:

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Produc...82E16817151068

fyi, 2 out of 3 NE reviews came from the same person name tom as according the link u provided, i also found a recent review from spcr on seasonic m12d unit for ur reference @ http://www.silentpcreview.com/article898-page1.html

Show 100 post(s) from this thread on one page