FYI G.Skill 2GBZX and Asus p5b

[bobdelt]

This G.skill ram does not work with the asus p5b.

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?Item=N82E16820231071

or the gigabyte ds3.

I had to run to best buy to buy a cheap stick of ddr2 just to post.

Even after I was able to post and enter the bios and set the correct voltage and timings, and then put the G.skill memory back in, it still wouldnt post.


As a result I just ordered this, its not ddr2 800, but I'm only running a Pent D at the moment, and benchmarks so it doesnt really matter.

https://www.zipzoomfly.com/jsp/ProductDetail.jsp?ProductCode=85206

Got it just in time for the rebate. Looks like great memory at a great price.

[Richard Dower]

Then again, will that memory work?...if it does do report back.
It's a rather depressing, have a new mobo and new memory and to discover they won't work with each other.

It's like going to a ball game and knowing which team will lose before it ends...

:-(

[bobdelt]

So it like going to a Cubs game?

[Vric]

If that could help, OCZ PC6400 Platinum XTC work on P5B (running that right now)

[Lestat]

the ram is rated at 1.9-2.0v @ DDR800 5-5-5

now i have shown with my ZX DDR800 that the sticker is wrong, mine infact shows 2.0-2.1v but it refuses to boot at anything under 2.3v in the bios.

i too have to boot with my el cheapo set then change the vdimm to 2.3 and then boot up.

if an overclock fails, your screwed as you have to reset the bios... and go thru all the ram swapping.. yada yada.

i would advise anyone with a gigabyte or other similar board to avoid all gskill ram untill gskill can program them correctly.

[theteamaqua]

ahh good to know, although i have OCZ it works jsut fine

[pcdoc1]

i would advise anyone with a gigabyte or other similar board to avoid all gskill ram untill gskill can program them correctly.You mean, until Gigabyte can fix their bios.... :confused:

[doco]

would these two g.skill rams work on the p5b??

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?Item=N82E16820231065

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?Item=N82E16820231073

[pcdoc1]

would these two g.skill rams work on the p5b??

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?Item=N82E16820231065

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?Item=N82E16820231073Yes.... http://www.xtremesystems.org/forums/showpost.php?p=1618028&postcount=39

[xpsentity]

This is really looking like a 965 issue with this particular ram (And ram nearly like it, ala ZX). It's something to do with the "intel only" thing conflicting with the 965 chipset maybe.

Plenty of people have no problems with it on 975.

First DS3, now P5B.

Anyway, the G.Skill guy has posted on it in the other thread, and has experienced the same problems on a DS3. Take a look there.

[bobdelt]

You mean, until Gigabyte can fix their bios.... :confused:

Well it happens with the Asus p5b and the Gigabyte DS3... I highly doubt both these companys have such errors in their bios. I think G.skill's ram isn't doing a good job at telling the bios how to run.

[pcdoc1]

Why are you suprised that budget ram isn't working with a new chipset?

[GSKILL TECH]

please check my post over there

http://www.xtremesystems.org/forums/showthread.php?t=109340&page=3

so sorry about the tourble

[bobdelt]

Why are you suprised that budget ram isn't working with a new chipset?


So budget = does not work ? Budget ram should be free then. And people are having problems with the higher end models too.

At least they have the balls to come to the forums, I've never seen a company do that before...